7.2

lol.

Im in your boat. I think i'm a fan of a total of five "musicals" ever made. I never liked the idea and dont even think this is one but being so close to it is it should be in tops.

I've seen musicals that are musicals from beginning to end and that's what I really consider musicals. This had dialogues and other stuff, like comedy.

But considered musicals, I'd enter Saturday Night Live if that's even considered a musical.

Nightmare before Christmas one of my all-time favs.

and

Hedwig.

Hahahahahaha.

I see it in the high 9's.

and what a time. could it ever be beaten?

Still I'd go with 9. There isn't that many movies like this and this movie is the originator and the influencer in so many of these types of films.

It's so original and enjoyable even for those that dont like musicals that it should be given special treatment. Somehow I dont think an 8 would do it.

If you look at whats above you’d see why it’s disrespected.

So Do I.
Naw 9.8 minimum. Its so much fun it doesnt feel like a musical.

^ same Grease and Hair are the only ones I can stand.. and Cabaret of course.

agree with like a 8.3