The Show was Better


The problems with the movie:
1) All the jokes were already used.
2) There was no laugh track
3) People could not relate to it. When the show was on, one of the reasons it was so popular is because people that worked in department stores or shopped in department stores could relate to the show. Them going on holiday and getting shot at was a little unrealistic.

What does anyone else think?

Dear sexy knickers I don't half fancy you meet me outside at 5:30 and we'll get it together

reply

[deleted]

Usually feature films based on TV series fail, but I'd still like to see this. Have you? Was this actually shown in theaters, or was it a TV movie that reunited the cast?

reply

I saw the movie for the first time about 30yrs ago...then took a second dose of it a few years ago.
I liked the movie (but i am probably biased as i watched the series regularly). The jokes are used from the series, but that happens with every sitcom that makes a feature film

reply

You're lucky to have seen this in the '70s. I'm hoping to track this down someday.

Did it lose anything when adapted to the big screen -- like laughs? And was the humor bawdier because the filmmakers didn't face the limits of television (though they seemed to get away with quite a bit there)?

reply

You can download the Torrent online..you may even be able to order it from Amazon.com

reply

that is very true. all of mr bean's jokes made it into the movie and then they just rehashed the hash.

Reading the paper can really be depressing. Mr. Dithers fired Dagwood again.

reply

Much of Mr. Harmon's lines seemed better suited for Mr. Mash. Harmon never came off as a "dirty old man" the way Mash did in the TV version. Mr. Humphries was written more as a parody of Mr. Humphries. As for the rest, I agree the jokes were sadly lacking. The bit about the Arab buying trousers was better suited to TV and should never have been used here, especially since it was edited down from the original. (Wherein he wanted to buy a pair of men's trousers for his head wife, but Humphries and Lucas were forbidden to actually touch her in order to measure her. The movie version omitted the wives and the rest of his entourage except the interpreter and used the "taking an inside leg on a man wearing a kilt" bit from TV with Humphries attempting to stick the tape measure up his robe. )

I *did* like how they made the movie's store set look more like a real department store. The TV show's set was way too small for a real department store, and there were only two departments on the entire floor. This made Captain Peacock's task of directing customers seem completely ridiculous, but fortunately, the writers were able to use this fact for comic effect on at least one episode when a customer needled Peacock for having an easy job. (Early shows had dialog and sound effects running in the backround which gave the impression that the floor opened out more towards the audience, which also lent credibility to the theme song's line about telephones being sold on the first floor along with "gents' ready-made suits")

reply

The problems with the movie:
2) There was no laugh track
What does anyone else think?

Some of us actually dislike laugh tracks!

reply

I dislike laugh tracks also, but I think this film feels a bit "off" because it's like a sitcom trying to find its footing as a feature film. I can't say it's entirely successful, but I even its failures are interesting. I loved the show and merely like this movie, which I gave 7/10 stars.

reply

Are you being served, like most british sitcoms, was filmed in front of a live audience. So the laughter is real, not fake. i personally like that.

reply

I suspect that a lot of shows with studio audiences still use laugh tracks for filler. Going to listen for one next time I watch this show, but my recollection is that some of the laughter did sound "canned".

reply

[deleted]

The show was much better. Films of tv seies are seldom satisfactory. A plot based around the store would hqve been more amusing. but it did have a few funny moments, and i have a certain affection for it as it is the last time the original cast were all together.

reply

The show was way better

reply

The movie has it's charm.

The different film quality and lack of a laugh track were strange at first but it's nice seeing the whole gang together when they were at their peak.

The follow up show, Grace & Favour (aka Are You Being Service Again?) was quite pleasant and worth tracking down if you haven't seen it already.

reply

I rewatched the whole run of the show and this movie not too long ago. As time went on the 'plots' (if you can call them that!) became more and more preposterous, and the show relied on the personalities of its stars - but they were up to it. I still love it.

reply

Have you seen the Australian version with Mr. Humphries? I'm not sure where to find that but I'd be curious to see it.

reply

I haven't!

reply