MovieChat Forums > Earthquake (1974) Discussion > Walter Matthau's Atrocious Cameo in Eart...

Walter Matthau's Atrocious Cameo in Earthquake


Watching Charlton Heston read the film's terrible, stilted soap opera lines, I'm reminded that Walter Matthau was offered that lead and -- being the discriminating fellow he was about scripts -- turned it down.

Instead, Matthau agreed to a rather embarrassing cameo as a drunk in a bar frequented by cop George Kennedy. Matthau wears an awful polyester shirt and pants and a great big floppy pimp hat and frankly -- its an embarrassment.

He looks terrible as the drunk(I guess he was doing things to his face makeup to LOOK drunk.) This was only a year after Matthau had played tough and cool and even sexy in the well-scripted and directed Charley Varrick. This was also barely a month since he had anchored the great 1974 thriller "The Taking of Pelham 123." What a comedown.

As I recall, Matthau as upset that the producers stretched out his "one scene short cameo" into cutaways that added up to about 6 or 7 "mini-scenes." I don't know if he sued, but he forced them to change his last name billing...to something unintelligble.

And they added the drunk character (with no view of Matthau's face; it was a different performer) to a later scene at the medical rescue building -- dancing and falling over.

PS. As it turned out, Walter Matthau never had to act a lead in any of the 70's disaster movies. The Earthquake cameo was his only, rather contemptuous contribution. Meanwhile, his Odd Couple buddy Jack Lemmon took the lead in Airport 1977 -- and rather redeemed a decade of wimpy roles as the heroic airline captain.

reply

I liked the drunk popping up throughout the movie. I was relieved he survived. People laughed in the theater when he was onscreen.

reply

You’re overreacting.

Also, I’ve never heard anything about Matthau being offered the lead. Only that producer Jennings Lang, who was friends with Matthau, offered him the cameo role and Matthau agreed to do it, without compensation, on the condition that he be billed under the name "Walter Matuschanskayasky," the last name being a long-standing "inside joke" that he had used for decades up.

reply

OK, maybe I'm overreacting.

I looked at Matthau's scenes again and truly he shines as a "true movie star" in the bar. I didn't like his clothes or his hat, and maybe the photography mottled his face, but yeah, that's Walter Matthau and it matters.

I suppose different stories abound about how Walter got that cameo (Jennings Lang was connected to Charley Varrick; his wife plays the madam of the Reno area brother in the film) but I HAVE read that Matthau was actually offered the lead first, and I CAN see why he would say no(the script) and do the cameo instead. Charlton Heston got a lucrative career in the 70's taking leading roles that the hipper generation wouldn't take -- and Matthau was actually rather hip.

I am a big Walter Matthau fan. From what I've seen, he never got a bad review and more often got very good ones. So perhaps I'm a bit protective of his reputation.

I'm glad the drunk survived, too.

reply

As you say, he really seems like a 'movie star' in the bar scene. The film has that 70s vibe, which is one of the reasons why I still enjoy it today.

I watch Airport (1970), The Poseidon Adventure, and The Towering Inferno today because they are good movies. Earthquake, though, is fun if you want to feel like you're back in the 70s for a few hours, and Matthau adds to that feeling.

reply

It's hilarious! I loved it.

reply

He's comic relief in an otherwise grim movie and maybe he had fun doing it (getting to dress as a pimp, be drunk, etc.)

reply

I'm the OP who put this diss on Matthau up there in the first place, and I return if only to say:

Hey, Walter Matthau was one of my absolute favorite movie stars...I'm not against MATTHAU, I just found his cameo a bit of a rejection of Matthau's....yes...COOL.

As a young movie fan, I watched with mounting pride and then some pleasant shock as he moved up...movie by movie, year by year, from a great supporting actor(to Kirk Douglas in Lonely are the Brave, Cary Grant in Charade, Gregory Peck in Mirage) to a great big bonafide star. The Fortune Cookie and The Odd Couple(a huge hit) did it. And look at Matthau in 1969...getting a million bucks to star with Streisand in the big Hello Dolly AND being romanced by Goldie Hawn and Ingrid Bergman in Cactus Flower.

I really dug Matthau's shift from comedy back to thrillers in 1973 and 1974: Charley Varrick, The Laughing Policeman, The Taking of Pelham 123 (the first and last of these are classics.)

And so...to see cool, deadpan actually rather tough Walter Matthau in that ridiculous hat and silly shirt and red velvet(purple?) pants...I just felt: "Ah, this is beneath Matthau." It just wasn't much of his persona at all. Imagine Steve McQueen or Clint Eastwood doing that part.

Oh, I guess they'd be funny , too.

I give up. Great scene!

reply