naked girls


After watching Shortcuts which I like a lot a few weeks ago, I went on with The Long Goodbye. What annoyed me is the images of female nudity within the later one. I am not against nudity at all, since I enjoy watching Shortcuts, a film with naked/half-naked female bodies displayed everywhere. I just can't see any reason why the scenes of nudity are necessary for The Long Goodbye. It didn't make any difference for the plot if a group of next-door girls are half-naked or not, nor was it helpful to any aspects of the film, thus it didn't make any sense for Altman using images like that. Anyone agrees?


reply

Wait, there are actually people bothered by hot chick nudity in a movie, just because there's no direct need for it in the plot?

reply

No need for them to be wearing panties for naked yoga. What kind of idiot directed this?

reply

Do we need an excuse for nudity? Can't nudity just be present? It wasn't blatant or offensive in the long goodbye, the women who were nude were comfortable being nude, it fit with their lifestyle.

reply

I think the naked/half-naked female neighbors scenes were way over the top, but I see what Altman was getting at. Marlowe seemed more emotionally involved with his beloved cat than the naked women next door, the gangsters, or anything else featured in the film. Talk about a male who loves a cat (love the cat food scene at start of film!). Overall the hits WAY outweigh the misses in The Long Goodbye (imo). :)

Martha Clark
Austin, Texas

reply

What I don't understand is why they were ALL naked. It was just unnecessary.

reply

I kinda find it funny when the Italian mobster guy is kind of astonished to see those like that, seeing as this is what Marlowe usually sees when he looks out the window.

But Marlowe doesn't mind it all. haha

I'm from Paris... TEXAS

reply

They were the only things worth watching. The rest is utterly ridiculous, a pointless deconstruction of the noir genre by a talentless smart-ass with nothing to say.

reply

i love how people try to find symbolism in everything





so many movies, so little time

reply

All that the nude women next door meant to me is that it shows the tapestry of the Hollywood Hills at the time. This is after the Love Generation and the subsequent darkness of the Manson Killings so there's gonna be a mix of transcendental spiritualism, hedonism, and good old neighborly relations on display.

reply