did this movie offened most christians??
did this movie offened most christians?? I need to know the answers becuase me and my friend are having a huge fight over it.
sharedid this movie offened most christians?? I need to know the answers becuase me and my friend are having a huge fight over it.
shareThe movie and the Album came out when I was a teenager.
I think for most of us young christians it was a blessing. It showed the faith in a modern light and also allowed us to discuss what the life, death and resurrection of Jesus really meant. It's summed up by "Jesus Christ, who are you what have you sacrificed?" We needed to undestand and discuss that.
I bought the album, my church took a trip to see the Broadway show and I made my Dad take me to the movie. Even today, on Easter Sunday we watch the Glenn Carter (2000) version after church.
Many were offended. There's no clear resurrection, Jesus divinity is not established, Jesus doubts, the piece is focused around Judas' perspective of Holy Week, In the Bible, Pilate didn't have a dream, his wife did, there are sacrilegious or goofy lyrics on occassion. Some wouldn't touch it with a ten foot pole, but we thought it was cool. It kept me going in the faith.
The older crowd was looking for a pious presentation of the Son of God like they had gotten with movies like The Greatest Story Ever Told or the Robe.
That's not JCSS.
The older school, traditionalists who can't see any humor in the situation yeah.
I know many though it should be more "realistic", not so blasphemous (which it definitely is).
I prefer Godspell myself though that too has it's problems.
The Humor when it comes to Jesus , such as this movie, which is an artistic rendering of the story, this sort of humoristic approach will only be told by a Jewish writer/director.
If anyone is looking for a more serious movie/documentary "Jesus of Nazareth" comes to mind - would be more appropriate.
Norman Jewison is only going to make you laugh about Jesus.
Don't look any further.
That's interesting. Seeing this in middle school and being able to relate to Judas was an early step on a loooong journey that lead to atheism. It was the beginning of a new kind of questioning, not questioning within the mythology, but questioning the mythology itself.
shareI am Christian, and I absolutely love this movie. The soundtrack is amazing, the acting is not only fun, but it is also convincing. When I first saw this movie when I was younger (and not at all religious) I considered it a blessing. My stepmother first showed it to me, and to be honest I always felt uncomfortable about her strong faith and being born again, but I really think this movie was a blessing. It was entertaining and also enlightening. I saw it when I was in middle school, and did not get "saved" until I was about 19, but it definately shined some light on a lot of my unasked questions. And again, the soundtrack is SO GOOD!!
shareJust the really stupid ones, which I would guess is about half of them.
shareThis movie doesn't offend my faith either, but I am offended by the people who think less of those Christians who are offended by Superstar. I can definitely understand how the representation of Jesus and his story, the very foundation of the religions that has impacted history the greatest, could be offensive to some. Like I said though, I am able to see pass that and just take it for a good musical.
shareI am a devout Christian and this is my favourite musical of all time. Like ukfan36, I can see how this COULD offend but the best way to combat that is to take it on the chin and view it as an alternative look at the story of Jesus. There are much more offensive films out there at the moment.
shareIt offends some, but not others.
My wife and I are both Christians, and we love the movie. But we do know people who were offended.
We got to see the musical when it came to Spokane several years ago, and there was a group of pastors and nuns outside the theater protesting. One of the pastors from our church was sitting right behind us, and we could certainly tell that he was offended. He refused to even applaud at the end.
Although this movie/stageshow contains just about every ethnic slur that one can think of; insulting whites, blacks, women, christians, jews (just to mention a few), it was the most popular broadway play of its time, and ran a long time in my town, Chicago in the early 70's. At that time I was 26 years old.
The music is masterful, but the lyrics sometimes made me cringe. The way it poked fun at the military did not help our soldiers who were dying by the hundreds...daily....in Viet Nam. The song..."Christians in *beep* Its A Crazy Little War" set us all back 100 years.
It offended some on the commentary someone stated that the Pope (John I think), enjoyed watching it and he watched a few times in his life.
share<<Although this movie/stageshow contains just about every ethnic slur that one can think of; insulting whites, blacks, women, christians, jews (just to mention a few), it was the most popular broadway play of its time, and ran a long time in my town, Chicago in the early 70's. At that time I was 26 years old.
The music is masterful, but the lyrics sometimes made me cringe. The way it poked fun at the military did not help our soldiers who were dying by the hundreds...daily....in Viet Nam. The song..."Christians in *beep* Its A Crazy Little War" set us all back 100 years. >>
Uh...ladylegend...you're thinking of "Hair" -- that's an entirely different movie. And the line is "Prisoners in *beep*," it's taken from an Allen Ginsberg poem about Vietnam casualties.
-----
I joined IMDB and all I got was this lame-ass signature.
"Christians in *bleep* is a crazy little war" I need to ask, what movie did you see? This song is not in Jesus Christ Superstar. I do not remember the military being shown unfavorably in Jesus Christ Superstar, they showed roman soldiers marching, and that is it.
I realize that this is 4 years too late, but if someone else comes here, that has not seen this Rock Opera ( Not a musical) I do not want them getting the mistaken perception you saw the film.." it's a dirty little war" is part of a song in the movie "HAIR",the name of the song is " three five zero zero", which does show the military in a not favorable manner, and takes place during the viet-nam war. but that movie was released long after the war was over.
So hate to do this, but you don't know s*** from shinola.
Sorry to say, citing your lyrics, you are thinking of "Hair", NOt JCSS.
I think I am taking all of this rather well.
Sorry to say, citing your lyrics, you are thinking of "Hair", NOt JCSS.
I think I am taking all of this rather well.
I am no longer a Christian, though as a child I was brought up as one. I started listening to JCS when i was 8 years old and really enjoyed it, i guess i never thought about how some Christians may be offended by it. Anyway, my mum didn't like it very much, never quite worked out why.
shareBit of a late comment but I'll say it anyway.
My school is putting this on at the moment, and there's Christians playing Jesus, Herod and some members of the chorus. I'm sure there's others as well. They are all fine with it.
However, I am aware that when it came out some people believed that as it sympathised to some extent with Judas it wasn't popular with SOME Christians.
I think it just depends how you take it.
Not at all, except for when the sick were all trying to get Jesus to heal them, and he gets all overwhelmed and says "There is not enough of me!" That was not Biblically accurate. But that's basically it so far. It is an awesome flick. And of course Ted's hair and rock star voice were great.
My latest husband- http://www.imdb.com/name/nm0402271/
[deleted]
No. And I LOVE the music and lyrics which are a witty update of how biblical characters might speak in modern terms. A LOT of it isn't biblical.
share