If you guys would stop picking apart someone else's grammar and spelling and actually pay attention to what they're saying and respect that others will have opinions different than yours (without insulting their taste), you won't look like the more ignorant (and elitist) schmuck.
Welcome to IMDB.
It's kind of a strange forum. To get some idea where the original poster dieing 4life was coming from -- previously having discovered a large number of posters are high schoolers -- I went to his profile and looked at his other messages. What other kinds of films did he like did he find stupid? I discovered there were no other messages. He only posted the two messages in this forum. He hasn't been back in five years.
Was his post a prank? Just a kid being mindless? Hoping to upset the macho adult men who (he would probably think)
absolutely love this film? We'll never know I guess.
I don't really agree with you and your film school pals, crocetti. That the ending isn't
the big payoff we moviegoers have a right to expect having invested time and brain cells into following the film. As with so many films, I think you have to understand the context. What may seem contrived now -- in 2010 -- may not have seemed contrived in 1968.
Hell in the Pacific came out at the height of the Viet-Nam War (which I fought both in and against). I felt it was an anti-war film when I first saw it, and a very intelligent one at that. There was also the anti-Asian sentiments alive in the US in the late 60s (also because of the war) which I also felt the film explored.
Japanese people during WWII were absolutely despised here in the USA. The idea that a gruff character like Lee Marvin would have to overcome his fear and loathing of the Japanese soldier (or airman) to survive added a lot of tension to the film I thought.
As for the ending, despite it being imposed on the production by the studio, I thought it was the perfect ending. That it
had to end that way actually.
What was the other or original ending? Anyone know?
[edited once for clarity]
reply
share