I don't think it's boring.
However, I do think it has dated very badly.
With the exception of Deneuve (at least for the most part), the acting has a cheap 'Play for Today' quality, as does the dialogue; the shaky camera work feels like a bad appropriation of the nouveau vague aesthetic; and the loud music cues during moment of horror are cheesy due to both their shock value and their 60s jazz-lite style.
Throughout the film I kept thinking, "He made this 3 years after 'Knife in the Water'?! But this feels so much less accomplished..."
I actually think Polanski is one of the most over-rated directors ever. For example, 'Rosemary's Baby' takes a ridiculous concept, makes it very believable throughout the film and then messes up at the end with the ridiculous coven scene. 'The Pianist' is sentimentalist schmaltz, 'The Ghost Writer' is drab escapism (and again, the ending is ridiculous) and 'Carnage' is vapid pseudo-intellectualism.
I can't really remember 'The Fearless Vampire Killers', 'Macbeth', 'Chinatown', 'Frantic' and 'Bitter Moon', but I do recall not being very impressed for much the same reasons (e.g. flawed verisimilitude).
reply
share