MovieChat Forums > Robinson Crusoe on Mars Discussion > Why were the aliens so obsessed with fin...

Why were the aliens so obsessed with finding Friday?


You have to be frightened of the overwhelming military technological capability of an alien race that can expend so much effort and expense to track down just one escaped slave. The movie doesn't explain why the high-tech aliens want Friday back so much.

I have a theory. The high-tech aliens aren't really looking for Friday. They're looking for the alien earthman who's with Friday, Cmdr Christopher Draper. The aliens don't want anyone else to know of their presence. The last thing they want is for Earth to know that an extraterrestrial species is trespassing into their solar system to mine a planet. It's clear that Earth's technology is far, far behind the high-tech aliens, but no doubt far along enough to cause serious problems if there were a military confrontation. The mysterious aliens prefer secrecy. The high-tech aliens have evidently no intention of making contact with a our planet Earth. They might be afraid of their technology falling into human hands and thereby quickly advancing Earth's technological base.

This movie was low budget but that didn't interfere with this movie's unique charm. I would have liked the movie's producers to at least have made a better effort to depict the high-tech aliens, instead of hiring Caucasian stuntmen and putting those guys into surplus spacesuits probably left over from an earlier science fiction space movie.

Would I like to see a 21st century remake of "Robinson Crusoe on Mars"? Heck, yes, as long as the film director doesn't try to insert some screwy politically correct message. I would actually prefer the new director follow the original as closely as possible. Please don't change the ethnicities of the two earth astronauts just for the sake of political correctness. That means don't hire Will Smith to be Cmdr Draper in a transparent attempt to bring out the black moviegoers. I liked the original Friday, which means finding another very tall, Hispanic guy for the remake. There was a real chemistry between Christopher Draper and Friday. Don't mess with it in a remake.

reply

Very plausible that the aliens wanted to find the earth man through Friday. I may also suggest that if slaves escaping was a rare thing. They might spend extra time & assets to hunt him down and capture him (especially alive) so they could then use him to set an example to frighten the other slaves into fear induced obedience. This, of course meant that once they captured him, they they might publicly subject him to some very unpleasant situations. They didn't appear to be beyond torture.

reply

Another take was that it was an illegal operation and that Friday was a loose end that needed to be silenced. You could say that our Solar System was proscribed and that if the Space Law Enforcement got hold of Friday, they would have been able to track the bad guys, which would explain why the Aliens didn't try to mine Earth.
But I think that probably having the Aliens hunt for Friday was thought to be a more interesting plot line than trying to have them learn to communicate better or learning to better survive on the planet, plot holes or not.

reply

[deleted]

Maybe the aliens put so much effort into finding Friday out of sheer vanity and stubbornness. Maybe they’re obsessive about their property. After all, if they’re so technologically advanced, why do they still need slaves in the first place? Is it just because they like to hang on to their traditions?



All the universe . . . or nothingness. Which shall it be, Passworthy? Which shall it be?

reply

I think the reasons hint at a much deeper and interesting story about "Friday's" background that should be explored in a sequel. In fact: Kenneth Von Gunden in his book "Twenty All-Time Great Science Fiction Films" suggests that the questions as to why the aliens were so interested in capturing or killing Friday would make an excellent story for a sequel.

reply

Excuse me, but as people of color are the fastest growing population of the USA and the world, having a person of color as the lead would not be a negative thing, but a positive thing. Maybe you should try to accept that, and not be so close-minded. (Better yet, try and accept this fact; remakes are not made for you and fans of the original movie, they're made to get new fans and movie goers who haven't seen the original. Sure, not all of them are great, and not all are successes, but then again, not all productions of Twelfth Night, Hamlet, The Tempest, You Can't Take It With You, or any other play of musical you'd care to mention are great or are successes, either.)

If the actor is good at what they do, it really doesn't matter if they are Afro-American, Latino-American, or Asian-American,so long as they can act the part convincingly (and Will Smith has played the lead hero very well in a lot of movies, as has Wesley Snipes, Denzel Washington, Cuba Gooding Jr., and last but not least, the man who paved the way for the above-mentioned gentlemen, Sidney Poitier!) A black actor or any actor of color isn't going to make a (possible) future version of Robinson Crusoe on Mars look any worse than a white actor. (Also, please be reminded that there have been black astronauts!)

reply

[deleted]

I never took it as them coming back to Mars just for Friday. Remember this dialog:

"Enemy come."

"When?"

"Soon."

"How soon?"

"Sixty suns."

"Sixty suns? That's two months. They're overdue!"

I always took it to mean that they were just coming back on their regular mining schedule, and that whatever slave detection sweeps they did simply keyed on and activated Friday's bracelet(s). They probably started chasing him because the system noticed he wasn't at the mining site at the time.

reply

[deleted]

It seemed that they routinely killed their slaves. Why make the expensive trip from the belt of Orion to Mars just for one that got loose and may or may not even be alive by the time they get there?

reply

[deleted]

[deleted]

I'd have taken the aliens more seriously if their space suits hadn't looked like leftovers from 'The Three Stooges In Orbit.' <G>

reply

Because the authors of this thing thought they needed some suspense and action... and, unfortunately, this is the best they could come up with.



"facts are stupid things" - Ronald Reagan

reply

Don't over think it. It's just drama.

reply