MovieChat Forums > Judgment at Nuremberg (1961) Discussion > 'We knew nothing about it.....Very few G...

'We knew nothing about it.....Very few Germans did.'


Hi Everybody,

This is what the lady servant, Mrs. Halbestadt, said. I'm not sure if I have the quote down verbatim, but this is basically what she said - and boy was it a pile of crap! This part of the movie was not fictional - it is fact that many Germans denied knowing about the exterminations when the war was over, yet, these people not only knew of it, but some encouraged it. It's horrific that something like the Holocaust even happened in the first place, and then you have morons who totally deny knowing of it. And who do they think will believe them anyway? I'm not beating up the Germans completely - I'm partially German from my maternal side, but come on, get real, people know crap when they hear it. The thought that the Germans would go so far as to deny it didn't even occur to me till I saw this movie and then I did some research of my own to find that, in fact, this was true of many Germans back then.

Was anyone else flabbergasted by this attitude?


“I got the feeling I was the man’s first date that wasn’t inflatable.”

reply

I actually think it is QUITE plausible that the extent of what was happening was NOT known by the populace at large.

Kinich-Ahau / Kukulcan in 2012!
Carpe tenebrae!

reply

I agree total B.S. there were plenty of German citizens who left in the 30's and tried in vain to tell the world what was happening.

reply

When I was stationed in Germany, I got to know an old Wehrmacht veteran, a tank driver (drove Panther Tanks). He told me that as close-knit German society was (and is), at the same time it was highly regimented. During the 30s, as the Nazis consolidated power for Hitler, the Gestapo instituted policies that would allow people to turn anyone in on any suspicion of subterfuge, subversion, or sedition. Meaning, a child could turn in his parents on the grounds they were not in league with National Socialism and/or were working against it.

Under those circumstances, people did well to mind their own business, and made sure they didn't mess around.

Gunther told me that they suspected what was happening to the Jews in Germany, Poland and France. When he was on the Eastern Front, it was widely known that the SS and other units were taking Jews, gypsies, Russians, and others out to ditches to be shot on the spot. At the same time, they didn't want to believe that there were death factories - Concentration Camps - designed to industrialize extermination by the thousands a day. That was completely unthinkable, because it hadn't happened like this before.

Most ordinary Germans didn't know for certain what was happening. We're talking about a highly regimented, closed society. If you, as a German citizen, were somewhere you had no business being, you stood a good chance of going to prison, or worse. If you had publications not approved by the Reich, you could be put in prison. So I generally believe them when they say they didn't know. They suspected, and some of those that did know did their part to help prisoners escape.

reply

[deleted]

Viet Nam and Iraq are not in the United States. It's easy to ignore or be ignorant of foreign policy. It is virtually impossible when it's happening right on your doorstep. That is the difference.

When they say they didn't know, I believe them. It's like, "Oh, I had a hunch, a suspicion. I figured it out with 99% certainty. But did I ever SEE someone shoved in an oven first-hand? Nein!"

reply

[deleted]

Well, Mrs. Bertholt, as part of the "nobility" and as wife of high-ranking military, certainly knew all there was to know, and obviously approved.


Proof?

As for the bourgeois, if they didn't know, it was because they lived under a rock.


???

How do you want to know what people knew back then what happened outside their country during a war?

In other words, I think German civilians couldn't help but know what was going on; however, did their best to enter a state of denial which enabled them to fabricate, embellish, or whatever in order to live with themselves.


Nonsense.

Most Germans knew that there were internment camps and POW camps - like the almost all other countries back then, including the Allies, had them as well.

About the "H." ("gassings") they first time heard from the Allies, after the (alleged) end of the war.





Yours,

Thusnelda



Wir sind die Toten
http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=VUpvKO0LyPE

reply

"Most Germans knew that there were internment camps and POW camps - like the almost all other countries back then, including the Allies, had them as well."


American internment camps for Japanese-Americans were not pleasant places, but compared to Nazi concentration camps they were like Club Med. Where would you rather have been interned, in Manzanar or in Auschwitz?

Germans knew that Nazi camps were horrible places. A jingle from as early as 1935 was "Lieber Gott, mach mich dumm, damit ich nicht nach Dachau kumm" (Dear God, make me dumb, that I may not to Dachau come).






reply

"Most Germans knew that there were internment camps and POW camps - like the almost all other countries back then, including the Allies, had them as well."


American internment camps for Japanese-Americans


...and other ethnic groups like Italian-Americans and German-Americans were known to the American public, like German internment camps were known to Germans.

Germans knew that Nazi camps were horrible places.


Proof?

A jingle from as early as 1935 was "Lieber Gott, mach mich dumm, damit ich nicht nach Dachau kumm" (Dear God, make me dumb, that I may not to Dachau come).


If this slogan actually existed, it just shows that somebody didn't want to be interned as such, nothing more. It says nothing about the conditions of internment.




Yours,

Thusnelda



Wir sind die Toten
http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=VUpvKO0LyPE

reply

Over a year since this lunatic last posted, yay!

reply


Bergen-Belsen - location - Germany
Sachsenhausen - location - Germany
Buchenwald - location - Germany
Ravensbrück - location - Germany
Flossenbürg - location - Germany
Dachau - location - Germany
Neuengamme - location - Germany
Mittelbau-Dora - location - Germany
Bernburg - location - Germany
Kaufering/Landsberg - location - Germany

Now thuSSy will argue how many of them were "labor camps" or just "transit camps" or how many of them are not in post-war German borders.
The hundreds of thousands who died in these camps are just as dead.

The end result is that the Germans knew.

THE GERMAN PEOPLE KNEW.

reply

[deleted]

[deleted]

Sir, no, they didn't KNOW.

And even if they did, what could they do?

You fail to understand, like so many others. Germany had become a MACHINE. Its inhabitants mere cogs, sprockets, pumps, valves, and levers. A cog cares not what happesn to the cam it actuates, so long as it actuates. Distill your morality for a few minutes and understand what that life was like. If you had any doubts, and voiced them, you could be turned into the Gestapo.

That's what socialism does - it turns human beings into materiel. To be used at the behest of the state. That's why I hate Democrats so; their ignorance of history and reality makes them reprehensible. They are so blinded with rage and envy they cannot see beyond themselves. If I could accept someone's extermination, I would accept theirs, for there is no earthly excuse for their behavior.

This is a fight between God and the Animal. We choose which side we are on.

reply

That's what socialism does - it turns human beings into materiel

Gotta love it when right-wingers try to portray the Nazis as "socialists". But hey, it says "National_sozialistisch_", so it must be right, lol, oh my...

reply

That's because it is. Nazism is a left-wing ideology. Apart from the murders and atrocities and racism, what is it about National Socialism do you really disagree with?

reply

Buddy, get a clue. Nazism is an extreme right wing philosophy. Communism is a far left philosophy. Both extremes are terrible.

reply

WyldeGoose thinks Nazism is a left-wing ideology. Pathetic. Maybe because Fox News tells him it is. To everybody else in the world it's refered to as right wing extremism and its own advocates proudly call themselves right wing extremists. They are also placed in the far right side of any parliament they happen to win votes in. Feel free to verify where they are placed in the European parliament. Also feel free to see where they statistically get their most votes from. Disgruntled conservative voters who think their former party doesn't take a firm enough stance against homosexuality, atheism, and doesn't maintain enough discipline and "the traditional order".

Hitler cooperated with the German conservatives led by Franz von Papen to get the desired majority in the Reichstag. Wouldn't that be very odd if they are a left-wing ideology? The Nazis had many supporters that were wealthy industrialists who liked him very much for taking a firm stance against all those marxists and their talks about "worker revolutions". Many because they saw themselves making a lot more money with all the Jewish businessmen out of the picture.

German socialists were one of the first sent to Dachau once Hitler came to power. Stomping out marxism in any way it could is one of the driving forces behind fascism, which is what nazism is.

Yes, it is clear they are on the same side of the political spectrum WyldeGoose, pardon my sarcasm.

You're free to believe whatever Glenn Beck tells you to but the historical and political evidence stands against you.

reply

No, they knew.

Germany was not a machine.

Nazi Germany was a system, a system designed for war and the elimination of undesired minority groups. This system was organized and run by people, the German people. They were not cogs,pumps or levers. They were the German people. They were the organizers, they designed and built the death camps, they were the ones who ran the railroad schedules, manufactured the gas.

You can hate Democrats, I'm no fan myself. But they also are people, people blinded by class warfare, redistribution of wealth, government intrusion into every aspect of daily life and intent on making usually self reliant Americans depentant on the government for everything.

I know this, because I'm here - just as the Germans knew about the attempted genocide of entire population groups based on ethnicity or religion.
They were there. They did it.

reply

Monday morning quarterbacks always like to think they would be the heroes who would step in and save the day. The reality is that even if you didn't agree and had a family who could be imprisoned or killed for protesting, most people would just try to stay under the government's radar.
There were heroes, exceptional people. I visited the Plotzensee Memorial in Berlin where Germans who disagreed with Nazi policies were also murdered. Not every human being is capable of such sacrifice. Most people just try to survive.











"..sure you won't change your mind? Why, is there something wrong with the one I have?"

reply

Not to mention huge numbers of the guards at the death camps were not German but ukranian, polish, latvian, estonian, austrian, hungarian, french dutch, belgians and other collaborators who joined up with the SS (far more eastern europeans than anything else tho)

reply

Monday morning quarterbacks always like to think they would be the heroes who would step in and save the day. The reality is that even if you didn't agree and had a family who could be imprisoned or killed for protesting, most people would just try to stay under the government's radar.
There were heroes, exceptional people. I visited the Plotzensee Memorial in Berlin where Germans who disagreed with Nazi policies were also murdered. Not every human being is capable of such sacrifice. Most people just try to survive.


This has jack all to do with being a "Monday morning quarterback". No one said the Germans who disagreed with genocide should have gone all vigilante and tried to stop anything. That would have been futile and I think everyone here knows that even speaking out against the Nazis or not possessing a fanatical attitude about the regime could have gotten a person killed. The discussion is about the Germans knowing about the concentration camps and what was going on and denying it.

The Germans that continued to deny that they had any knowledge after the regime was over weren't in any danger of being killed. They had no reason to lie or feigned ignorance except to distance themselves from actions that were and are viewed by most people as abhorrent and inexcusable. That has nothing to do with trying to "survive" as you put it and everything to do with shifting blame and absolving oneself of guilt and shame.

Every sane person knows the holocaust was made up. I mean in the f'ing torah it says 6 million jews have to vanish for them to inherit Palestine. They've been claiming 6 million have been killed for over a thousand years.


Who is "they"? Scholars and sane people? The Holocaust happened. Deal with it.

reply

[deleted]

Those were all concentration camps, basically prison camps from which people did serve time and were released.

The deaths were ramped up after 1942, so it could easily just been the same as living next to attica or sing sing

The death camps were all positioned outside Germany (Poland basically)

reply

About the "H." ("gassings") they first time heard from the Allies, after the (alleged) end of the war


I don't accept that. There were thousands of soldiers involved with working at the camps. It is incoceivable that they never spoke to their family about what was going on. The Jews in the ghetto were aware of camps. Again ir is inconceivable that the German citizens were unaware of their existence and that the disappearance of Jews in the community were to populate these camps.

Jewish sympathisers were hiding these poor souls knowing the fate that was in store for them.

You paint an innocent picture of the German race back then. Whilst not all were guilty of genocide or Xenophobia, there were plent that were.

Before the war Kristallnacht was not just a military led obscenity but involved thousands of German citizens.

Thinks he knows a total strangler online! .....Diablo

reply

My maternal grandparents are from Nuremberg, they grew up during the war and they told me that there were rumours about what was going on with but had no idea to what extent. They were from average families that did not support National Socialism and did well to mind their own business.

They told me this two years ago, it was the first time they had really spoken about the war to me. They said they loved Germany so much and it was such a beautiful country. I think they’re deeply ashamed at what happened. I think I would be too.


"Ahh, it's great to be young and insane" - Michael Keaton
The Dream Team

reply

[deleted]

Read the books "Storm of War" by Andrew Roberts and "Ostkrieg" by Stephen Fritz. Both have come out in the past year or so and are damning in their evidence of both the Wermacht and the majority of civilians were aware of the concentration camps and what was happening. In fact, many more of the German Army were involved than previously aware of.

German generals were surreptiously taped in in Scottish castle where they were being held. The Generals, to a man, said "We are going to tell everyone that we knew nothing about what was going on"

Many German soldiers took pictures of the killings they participated in and sent those pictures home, along with letters describing in detail what they both saw and did. Those civilians who lived close to the camps, like Dacheau, complained of the stench of the camps.

There is an incredible scene in the movie "Schindler's List" where the Jews are being transported by rail to Auschwitz. A little boy in the field near the railroad tracks sees the cattle cars the Jews are in and draws a cutting motion across his throat.

They knew.....or pretended that they didn't know.

reply

http://www.guardian.co.uk/uk/2001/feb/17/johnezard

Here's your proof. Goldhagen is your proof. Studies done by the US armies on the German population even show that 37% didn't deny that the extremination of Jews was for the safety of the Reich (the anwer should have been like 0.000001% in a normal country).

You've also said (in a previous post) that the Allies didn't know about the Holocaust before 1945. Well, I think we both know that this is a lie. I'm mentioning Auschwitz solely, however it was easy to assess what was going on in other camps in occupied Poland just by what was happening in Auschwitz. Witold Pilecki's reports from the time he spent in the camp (volunteered to enter to confirm the Home Army's fear of an extremination going on), Rudolf Vrba's report on his time spent in Auschwitz (escaped) and the Allied aerial-photos taken in 1944.

reply

There were many camps near many cities, with constant killings and gassings going on. No one around them knew what the smoke meant, constant human ash falling, and the smell, and didn't know? Yeah, right.

I think the people in the film were to represent those who knew, but didn't want to know, as well as those who suspected/heard rumors and didn't want to know the real truth. A lot of people knew or guessed, but were scared.

I'm just guessing here. I don't know. I just can't even imagine the type of cruelty that went on in that time of Hitler, his minions and supporters.

reply

luverofmovies- I agree. When I graduated from college back in '79 I went to Germany to work in a Youth Hostel. One of my German co-workers who was my age had a father who had been in the Army in WWII.

Even all those years later it seemed to be very difficult for Germans to deal with what happened. This young guy told me his father had "only been a corporal" and the war was over soon after he joined the Army. It was as if he wanted to minimize his family's involvement in any way.

I imagine that the guilt would be terrible, even guilt by association, to realize that you stood by and did or said nothing. Yet again, in Nazi Germany, doing or saying the "wrong" thing could get you killed.

And let's face it, a lot of the world knew something very bad was happening. I recall something about the Red Cross being allowed to inspect some of the camps. The conditions were supposedly better and "humane" at those camps. But really, why didn't the Red Cross object to people being held prisoner who had done NOTHING wrong? The world turned a blind eye.

reply

Dachau was the first concentration camp built in 1933 located fairly close to Munich - in fact you can take the train there...The German population knew of the existence of concentration camps and knew of deportations to the East and there was an entire bureaucracy set in place that profited from the appropriation of Jewish property etc that the German people largely accepted it as normal way of life in their society as incredulous as it seems today...Its a terrible legacy and to place blame on the ordinary citizen is a fruitless effort - it was a madness that took over the German nation at that time and hopefully a review of those historical events will prevent something like this from ever happening again..

reply

[deleted]

As far as the servants were portrayed in "Judgement at Nuremberg" were con-
cerned, you could feel just by looking at their faces (especially the woman)
that they knew (or suspected) and were ashamed.

I'm not defending real life people like these actors depicted, but I think that
many of them were afraid for their own lives to speak out. It would have taken
real courage for them to speak out and "take a stand" against Hitler and his
atrocities.

Over twenty five years ago, around 1985 I met a vacationing elderly couple from
Germany at a State Park near where I live. They were friendly until I asked
their ages. They said "we are 75, why do you ask?" I said "then you were young
adults during World War II?" They then replied "yes----" and their smiles were
replaced by a chilling almost sinister look. We just stared at each other for
a few seconds, and then the woman said "we go now. Nice to meet you."

They knew.

reply

Wow!!! I just hope you are never part of a jury.

reply

Was anyone else flabbergasted by this attitude?


Flabbergasted? No. Disgusted? Yes.

Like a few other people here have said, quite a few of "regular" German citizens knew what was going on the death camps. How could they not? Unless they were blind, deaf and dumb, they had to have known something was up. Granted, some might have not known the extent of things, but most were aware that something unpleasant (to put it mildly) was going on. Millions of people (or even thousands) don't simply "disappear". Does anyone who thinks most of the German citizens thought the people that disappeared forever just moved away? There were Germans who actually hid Jews from the Nazis. Why were they willing to hide people who were, according to some, were not being spirited off to certain death?

A mass movement of people into ghettos and forced on trains is pretty obvious. There's no need to provide "proof" for that - it's obvious. There's film footage of it for crying out loud. It wasn't exactly kept a huge secret.

reply