MovieChat Forums > Sleeping Beauty (1959) Discussion > Selflessness, not blindly obeying

Selflessness, not blindly obeying


I personally believe that Aurora wasn't just a meek, blindly obedient person. Some people are giving her a lot of flack, saying that she isn't a good role model like the more modern princesses. But in my opinion, giving up her dream guy in order to marry for the good of her kingdom is something that required a lot of bravery. Not every girl has to be boisterous and tomboyish in order to be brave and kind, and the first 3 princesses are some examples of this. Aurora especially was very mature, and can actually teach people about the value of selflessness.

reply

I think most of the hate on Aurora comes from the scene where she cries after just meeting Phillip. You have to admit that nowadays it does seem a little ridiculous, but it is the old Disney cliche of girl/boy meet and fall in love in 1 day. However, that same weakness could be attributed to Phillip because he also is immediately smitten with Aurora and tells his dad he won't marry the princess. When I honestly think about it, I don't feel we get to know Aurora well enough to deem her weak or not. I mean Phillip acts smitten but then also slays a dragon, escapes Maleficent, etc. Aurora basically sings in the woods, meets a guy, goes home and gets upset because she finds out she is betrothed, hits her finger on the spindle, falls asleep, etc. And really, it is a valid reason to cry when you are being forced into a marriage. Yes part of her tears are because of Phillip, but I would also be upset at 16 if my guardians told me they had arranged a marriage for me as a child. Plus, what was Aurora supposed to do in that situation? Isn't it just as weak if she refused to do what the fairies said because she had met someone for 20 minutes in the woods? Wouldn't Aurora seem rather bratty to refuse for that reasoning? In my opinion, the development for Aurora is just not there so it is actually unfair to call her weak. A better critique would be to say she isn't as fleshed out as other Disney heroines. I mean Phillip is more fleshed out than her!

reply

I never thought about that part of Aurora before. The fact that she went along with the fairies did show that they raised her well. And as someone else mentioned, take how she reacts when she meets Philip. She's smitten at first and caught up in the moment. But she doesn't swoon in his arms and run off with him. She makes arrangements to get to know him properly later on. Not in the forest but in her home - intending for her 'aunts' to be there as well.

But let's face it, there's not much you can do with this princess. The character in the source material pricks her finger, falls asleep and has to be rescued.

I'm gonna die of long hair!

reply

"I think most of the hate on Aurora comes from the scene where she cries after just meeting Phillip."

I think it is sad that so many people have not seen this movie or understand/appreciate what is going on in it. Artistically, it's beautiful and story wise, it's great, even if Aurora is not in it a lot. But her crying never came off to me as weak; it came off as human. Again, she had just met someone she may actually like. she's so happy at this moment, has this beautiful new dress and cake and within a flash, she is told her entire life is a lie. That not only can she never meet this man again, but she will be FORCED to marry someone else. And for all she knows this prince could be 80 years old or look like King Hubert. So yea, I can see her breaking down and crying realizing what she is being told is about to happen.

And despite all that, she's going along with it because she knows it is 'her royal duty'. Luckily, it turns out that her prince was the young man in the forest. But I think that fact that, even unhappily, she was about to marry this man she didn't know was very brave of her and she deserves some credit for her grace and selflessness.

reply

Exactly. I think Aurora's a good role model.. She dreams about love and can be naive but at the end of the day, she did what was right for the kingdom even though it broke her heart. That seems to be forgotten by a lot of people who watch this film.

reply

Gosh my answer comes 3 years after most of the other posts. Well, that's nothing compared to the 100 years the kingdom slept.
Here's the thing. Yes, I realize each generation/century alters the story a bit. but the core should stay the same or else, give it a new name and stop calling it sleeping Beauty or La Belle au Bois Dormant or whatever.
Changing the very early version from a rape to a kiss was a charming adjustment. The story is still basically another version of Persephone or a girl maturing archetype At 16 she gets to close her finger (bleeds-)on a prick.
She sleeps or goes under like Properine/Persephone. REawakens and marries. Okay very messy. but it was the model for a girl's adolescence for millennia until Title IX in the West at least. the correspondence in lit/folklore is never a one-to-one correspondence to actual human experience so it's pointless to try to interpret every detail. Anyway, altering the story to make her a Joan of Arc/Don't-rain-on-my-parade heroine just changes the story. it's not Sleeping Beauty anymore. ANd Lastly. I thought we were supposed to like diversity. Must all girls be like Pocahontas or they're just inferior? Sorry, Mary, you're second class citizen because you're not a dynamic person.

reply

[deleted]

It's a marvelous movie apparently not for everyone. Let them watch Human Centipede (proof not all Nazis died) and I just don't want to pick favorites anymore. So many are so good. Favorite child? favorite book? favorite flower or dessert?

reply

Words can't describe how much I love this post. I love Aurora and wish she got more appreciation.

reply

The 21st Disney century princesses reflect 21st century "screw the patriarchy" values. The princess in "Sleeping Beauty" is the product of a more thoughtful, mature, literate time.

reply

June 29, 2020 Monday 2:05 p.m.

The best kind of love is sacrificial; one that not only demonstrates commitment on a deep personal level, but one that also symbolizes the purest example of any kind of relationship that is bound by mutual self-giving love. Aurora shows that she understands what is truly at stake. She is mature and responsible.

~~/o/

reply

Aurora isn't the heroine of the film, the three fairies are the hero of the film She isn't so much a major character, as what the heroes and the villain are fighting over.

She gets no respect because her personality doesn't matter to the plot, if the fairies and Malifecent were fighting over a block of wood nothing much would have changed.

reply