why the movie rated so high?
i've just finished the movie, and feel tired and exausted,
just an average movie i think, not so good, why the 8.2?
this movie is a classic on many different levels.
-the acting is superb
-the script was 'decades' before it's time using terms such as 'rape' (a riaque subject matter to begin with back in that era), 'panties' (seldom if ever, heard on film), 'sperm', and countless others.
The score is a masterpiece by Duke Ellington (who has a cameo as 'Pie-eye', which is very similar to 'Pie-o-my' if your a Sopranos fan)
This film ranks right up there IMO with DR Strangelove, another masterpiece. By the way, these are more than just films, but rather: art.
There is not a boring character in this movie, from James Stewart on down to Muff, the dog. They are all interesting and keep your attention. I loved the scenes with Stewart and Scott sniping at one another - the judge was excellent, and you really felt bad for Mary Pilant. I love the sound track. But my main reason for loving this movie is the one and only Jimmy Stewart. This truly was probably his best film, next to Mr. Smith.
This movie was excellent and it broke many rules in its day. Those who wonder why this is an excellent movie will probably also wonder why Tom Sawyer and Huck Finn are great literature.
BTW, I think Mannion was guilty as sin and not insane at all.