MovieChat Forums > The Twilight Zone (1959) Discussion > Walking Distance vs A Stop at Willoughby

Walking Distance vs A Stop at Willoughby


Similar themes, both from the 1st season.

Which of these two do you prefer and why?

reply

I prefer Walking Distance. My reviews:

Walking Distance: This is one of my favourite episodes. There are some really nice moments here, I enjoyed the interactions and the performances of the actors. I like the journey that the character goes on and how it affects him. It's just a very enjoyable, good natured episode that I really connected with. 10/10

A Sop at Willoughby: I enjoyed this episode. It was an interesting premise with a good twist. The ending is somewhat ambiguous. However you interpret it, this is a really good episode. 8/10

reply

Well observed.

I wish the ending of Willoughby was indeed a little less ambiguous even though my wife and I both interpret it as Gart getting off the train at Willoughby and finally enjoying the life he wanted all along.

Walking Distance had a great message. When his father suggested that instead of looking behind him (to the past), he should look for happiness looking forward. Great message.

reply

That's how I interpreted it too.

reply

I interpreted it as....

spoiler:
he jumped off a moving train and died. Willoughby was the afterlife where he rest in peace aka: heaven. That's why the funeral home is called Willoughby.

It's one of my favorite episodes 10/10. I like idyllic small towns like Mayberry and Bedford Falls, also.

reply


Yeah, I wasn't clear. When he stepped off the Stamford train he died but when he stepped off the Willoughby train he went to Willoughby to live the "life" we most wanted.

reply

That episode reminds me of "The Bewitchin' Pool" episode with the brother and sister who jump in a pool and end up in a place with a "grandma" taking care of many kids.

It's a fantasy show so I guess they're all in the Twilight Zone.

reply


My favorite part of The Bewitching Pool is the reasonable sized hanks of cake that Ain't T portions out to the kids. All I would need is a pot of coffee, a hank of that cake, and a couch to take a nap afterwards on.

reply

It can be interpreted that he went to heaven or some sort of paradise, that death was the only means available and the price to escape as it obviously cost him his life but he wasn’t cognizant of it when it did happen. It reminds me of the old Moody Blues song, “Knights in White Satin”. “Just what you want to be, you’ll be in the end.”

reply

Walking Distance is the better of the two. Sometimes this episode is knocked for being too "talky" (expositing too much), but at least it doesn't have Gart's boss and wife.

reply

Walking Distance.

More relatable.

reply

Oh, “Walking Distance” with Richard Long for sure! It touches upon themes that we ALL have. Who hasn’t yearned for the past or the idyllic times of our youth? Who hasn’t wondered “If only I could go back, even for a visit?” The irony was that he was the one who gave himself his injured leg, he didn’t mean no harm to his younger self but that’s fate for you. It’s also ironic that his father was willing to believe in the reality of the situation however unlikely we may be to come to his conclusion that this was indeed HIS son and that for reasons unexplained he did come back.

Like a father, a good father he then gave him the best advice anyone could give. To find the good in where he was now instead of looking back. Yeah, it’s “Walking Distance” by a mile.

reply


I don't think Richard Long was in Walking Distance.

reply

Right! It was Gig Young. My bad.

reply

Walking Distance for me. Also, it's a sunny episode, while it always feels dark in A Stop At Willoughby, the dream scenes set on old-time Willougby aside. The "today" reality part is just plain dark and depressing. Gig Young's character in WD always either drives or walks. He's healthy, and he looks it. James Daly looks way older than the age he was given in the show (36!); and he doesn't look healthy, either. Gig looks like he's ready to make a change of pace in his life, while Daly looks like his next step will be in a mortuary, which is apparently, and ironically, ends up when he steps off the train.

Entrapment is a theme in both of these early TZ episodes, and it's repeated throughout the series run.

reply