The Obsolete Man


I've always been moderately entertained by this episode, because I think the overall message is good: the individual has worth, has rights that ought to be respected, and that we have a better society when those rights are respected; and it also has the message that an oppressive state that would crush the individual is evil.

Apart from that, I have never been overly impressed with the episode. The brutal, totalitarian state is far too accommodating of Wordsworth the dissident. It generously allows him his choice of how he is to die, thus permitting him to expertly orchestrate the humiliation of the nation's totalitarian dictator. Real dictatorships don't work that way. They don't smugly accommodate dissidents' final wishes; they crush them ruthlessly. They don't offer a choice as to the method of execution; they just take you out behind the courtroom and put a bullet in your head. The dictator doesn't pay you the respect of a personal visit; one of his extremely junior flunkies signs your death warrant, and you are carted off to your doom. The victim has no power. The lone individual is doomed, and without hope.

I like the message, but I can't suspend disbelief and buy into the story.

reply

You kind of have to suspend disbelief to watch The Twilight Zone.

reply

It generously allows him his choice of how he is to die, thus permitting him to expertly orchestrate the humiliation of the nation's totalitarian dictator.


How did that work out for him?? LOL, well, that certainly didn't work out well, but that was a circumstance that was unforeseen. I'm sure that was the last time they let a dissident have his execution live or at least in the manner and circumstance of his choosing.

The dictator doesn't pay you the respect of a personal visit..


I think the Chancellor was a dickhead but I don't think the Chancellor was the head dick.

reply

It is my favorite episode with Burgess Meredith.

reply

I like all of his episodes. I think Obsolete Man had the best written, but I enjoyed Printer's Devil (a rare 1 hour favorite) and Mr. Dingle the Strong as a guilty pleasure. Time Enough at Last is iconic in the Zoneverse, but probably my least favorite Meredith episode.

reply

It may be that you're taking too literal an approach to this episode, and to the series as a whole. It's fabulism, which can encompass satire & allegory while still being its own distinct sort of storytelling. You're right about real-life totalitarian governments, of course ... but this is finally a story about the inner world, the human condition, rather than the literal outer world. It's about two very different modes of experiencing life, two very different modes of meaning & purpose for human beings. It's about those famous words from Camus:

In the midst of winter, I found there was, within me, an invincible summer.

And that makes me happy. For it says that no matter how hard the world pushes against me, within me, there’s something stronger – something better, pushing right back.


Romney Wordsworth dies, but he's not defeated. In fact, he dies victorious by keeping faith with his own beliefs.

reply

Well said - thanks for posting this!

reply