MovieChat Forums > The Twilight Zone (1959) Discussion > Talky Tina or Willie The Dummy?

Talky Tina or Willie The Dummy?


Willie

reply

Tina

reply

It's more debatable as to whether or not Willie is even real which makes him, at least in my estimation, more interesting.

But I will concede Tina has the better catchphrase.

reply

"My name's Talky Tina and you better be nice to me!" I'd be pretty scared if I heard THAT coming out of a doll! lol

I'm sure this was a nod to a popular doll of the time, Chatty Cathy. I had one of those but she had no homicidal tendencies.

I think the Talky Tina episode could be taken in two ways. First, a total supernatural creepy episode with an angry doll who had real powers.

The other possibility is that Eric was a bit unhinged. He indicated that he and his wife couldn't have children. Since she had a daughter, it was probably an infertility problem on his part. Christie was his stepdaughter. She called him "daddy" and seemed to love him, but Eric was so resentful and bitter about not having a biological child, that he lost his mind. He "heard" the things that Tina said because of his own unresolved guilt over his cruel behavior towards Christie. He may have put the doll on the stairs without realizing it. Later he "tripped" over it and fell to his death because of his guilt over the way he treated Christie. Either that or Christie put the doll there in the hope that stepdad would trip over it!

Interesting that the names Christie and Tina are both nicknames for Christine. I sometimes think that Tina was Christie's alter ego and in her teen-age years she would no longer have put up with her stepfather's abusive behavior. She would have done something bad to him. But this way, the doll took care of her problem for her.

reply

Tina is more legendary.

But based on the creep factor, I'm going with Willie on this one. While Tina is frightening and possibly more dangerous from what we saw, Willie's evil laughter alone (the laughs from a certain movie killer doll remind me of Willie's) creep me out more than all of Tina's catchphrases. I know Tina's lack of personality and the way she delivers those threats so "innocently" is what makes her scarier to some, but I rather not even look at Willie from the TV screen. :D

reply

I think Willie was more dangerous. Based on what he did to his human master alone would be a worse fate.

reply

I agree with that.

reply

Talky Tina = creepier.

reply

The idea that Christie could be working through Tina is cool. But the notion that Willie might just all be in Jerry's head is even cooler.

How about if I threw in Caesar from "Caesar and Me"? How would he stack up against these two?

reply