MovieChat Forums > Pal Joey (1957) Discussion > Joey Evans is despicable

Joey Evans is despicable


First time I've seen this musical in any form but I am completely turned off by Joey. He is not charming, handsome, or funny as imdb says. He feeds coffee and donuts to a dog. He's not nice to anyone, especially women but also not his piano player friend either. Turns me off. (The only redeeming value so far is Rita Hayworth's ZIP. Fun number.) I'll finish watching the movie but only because I'm hoping his character gets his comeuppance in the end. I'm curious why people like this movie with a central character so unappealing.

UPDATE: Nope. No redemption. He treated Linda like crap when she came to him at the end and offered marriage. OK, I did get the impression that he loved her but this guy needs major therapy. I have read that the movie is not very much like the original stage play so it might be interesting to see a production of that to compare. But so far the Pal Joey reputation (aside from the songs which I know many of were not written for the musical) is lost on me.

reply

Sinatra actually softened his character for the film. He was more unlikable in the stage musical.

I personally saw no point to this film, except for the songs, which you can easily listen to online or from your CD's, like I do.

reply

Agree. The songs are marvelous, but the story is pointless - it's just a shithead getting away with being a shithead. Why film a story about such a person, when assholes who get away with it are everywhere in real life?

I was actually angry at the end, they tried to make a Hollywood happy ending out of some poor girl letting herself into years of misery.

reply