MovieChat Forums > Calamity Jane (1953) Discussion > More bautiful - Calamity or Katie

More bautiful - Calamity or Katie

posted 10 years ago by tarot400
5 replies | jump to latest

My vote goes for Katie - her figure alone is so sexy and she moves in a very beguiling way!

[–] purplish-1 9 years ago

My vote goes for Katie - her figure alone is so sexy and she moves in a very beguiling way!

That was the point of her casting. She was perfect for the role.

I found Calamity to have a bit more charisma and life in her personality. But as far as charming, Katie wins because she is such a "woman."

[–] kurtbrian14 9 years ago

omg are you kidding? Doris was smok'n hot when this film was made, and her dance numbers called for a real athlete.

[–] Sweet_With_A_Shot_Of_Sprinkles 9 years ago

Katie was a Plain Jane compared to Calamity. I'm going by natural beauty alone. Doris Day is the gorgeous gem with and without that cake up makeup...the ballroom scene proved that to be the case.

[–] AssetsonFire (149) 5 years ago

I'll take the one who looks like Anne Hathaway over the one who looks like Dennis the Menace.

[–] jdforyou1983 (1470) 4 years ago

Calamity