MovieChat Forums > Key Largo (1948) Discussion > Rocco whispers to Nora

Rocco whispers to Nora


Wonder what Johnny Rocco whispered to Nora?

reply

Yeah, I actually did. Kind of displayed a double standard that continues to exist today: sex is taboo while violence is completely permissible. I believe the movie showed at least three or four people shot to death, while a couple of sexual comments must be whispered.

I'll bet he was asking her if she had ever imagined sleeping with a man as famous as he. And if she wanted to fulfill that fantasy. Or something similar.

reply

I think the implication is that he wanted some form of perversion so filthy he couldn't say it aloud. Not regular sex, but water sports or some sort of heavy S/M thing. He may also have hinted that he wanted to have her with the old man watching, like a passive spectator.

reply

Asking for regular sex is "filthy" enough when a stranger says it to a good girl with "morals", especially morals that were prevalent in the 1940s. We all know what he meant, he wanted to have his way with her.

reply

Another explanation to the dirty talk one is that he was actually trying his brand of "sweet talk", offering to take her with him as his moll, trading up from the lush who he's obviously tired of and disappointed with. Rocco was impressed with Nora, liking the way she stood up to him - bar the spitting, of course, likening her to an old flame of his youth.

He whispered his offer because his current squeeze was in the room.

I think is borne out as well in that just before they all leave he whispers again, as if giving her a final chance and shrugs when she doesn't respond, as if to say, "well, your loss."

If it was the conventional 'dirty talk to unsettle her' explanation then that second whisper makes no sense.

reply

Water sports lol. Reddeer5, you are one funny dude.

reply

[deleted]

Maybe it's better not to know? The imagined is worse than whatever he might have said aloud?

Whatever it was, it certainly couldn't have had the impact that it could/should have, given the restrictions of the code and censorship.

The effect was definitely creepy.

reply

I think it's better we don't know.

The Nameless

I am not what I am

reply

[deleted]

Sweet Nothings

reply

[deleted]



He whispered something perverse and filthy of course. Good move to whisper. Our minds do a better job of filling it in. Don't think he asked her to go with him. He knew she wouldn't go. What he asked her was, "How about you and me.."
and when she didn't respond, "Well, your loss..".

reply

[deleted]

i have always wondered that too. maybe it is just one of those hollywood things that you will always have to wonder.

"You're not a star until they can spell your name in Karachi."- Humphrey Bogart

reply

Actually, in Bacall's Autobiography it was revealed that Edward G. Robinson whispered:

"your breasts are tilted to the left"

reply

king,

If you're telling the truth, that's a good story, but still disappointing. I've always liked to believe that Robinson actually whispered to Bacall a really, really funny joke, in an effort to get her to crack up during the filming of what was supposed to be a very tense, menace-filled scene!

Matthew

reply