MovieChat Forums > It's a Wonderful Life (1947) Discussion > How did audiences react in 1947?

How did audiences react in 1947?


It’s interesting how the film is a pretty straightforward drama for the first two thirds of the film but then suddenly takes on a supernatural/sci-fi twist when Clarence shows up and George sees what the world would be like if he was never born. Were audiences weirded out by this in 1947 since such a “plot twist” movie had never really been made before?

reply

The film came out right after a terrible war. I'm sure people were ready for fantasy and miracles. I'm sure it was well loved when it came out. I know it wasn't a blockbuster but ticket sales can mean lots of things (perhaps the film's title seemed a bit twee for many).

reply

It was well recieved It was nominated for 5 Academy Awards including best picture.

reply

It doesn't surprise me since it was awesome. I assumed audience number wise it was part of the wonderful sleeper category like The Wizard of Oz and Willy Wonka.

reply

Oh how I would have loved to have seen the Wizard of Oz and Willy Wonka in the theater. Such a different time and to see these magical movies would have been amazing

reply

Good question .. I still can’t imagine what it was like to go see this movie at a theater in 1947.

reply

It starts off with the supernatural by showing two angels talking to each other and recruiting a wannabe angel 😇.

There were plenty of supernatural movies in the 30s and 40s. Topper films were popular.

reply

People were no less sophisticated in 1947 than they are today.

reply

This failed big time. I think people knew it was patronizing.

reply

It didn’t do well financially and critics were mixed, but it was praised enough to get a bunch of Oscar noms.

When the copyright expired in 1974 it was shown on multiple TV channels every Christmas and that’s when it found its way into people’s hearts.

I guess it’s a good movie to watch at home with the family.

It’s now a towering classic of cinema. Funny the journey that some films have.

reply

I'm glad Frank Capra lived long enough to see it become a classic.

reply

Fully.

reply