MovieChat Forums > Double Indemnity (1944) Discussion > Neff Near Death from a Shot to the Shoul...

Neff Near Death from a Shot to the Shoulder?


Not buying it. Not too far away from the "Monty Python and the Holy Grail" line: "It's just a flesh wound!"

reply

Where do you get "near death"?

reply

That's the point. They act like he's dying, or at least, very badly wounded, after being shot in the shoulder. Come on! Is he that much of a pussy?

reply

He's starting to pass out from blood loss. Hello? And it's your assumption that "It's just a flesh wound." The bullet could've shattered bone and torn through whatever tissue was in its path.

reply

Exactly. There's a myth that gunshots to the shoulder, or the arm or the leg are just debilitating and not potentially lethal. Any gunshot wound can kill. Hit the wrong artery or vein, or don't get the wound treated quickly enough, and people die.

reply

You're a doctor, right? Nope.

But, it's a movie. Shoot him in the gut or something where we get the point better. Not that difficult.

reply

You're obviously a troll. If you were really as stupid as your post makes you look, you couldn't have turned on your computer.

reply

Poor baby! I love the random cut-and-paste retorts! :-)

reply

That's the only way you would get it? Shot in the stomach would leave him dead before he would be able to get to the office, let alone tell his story. Weakening from blood loss from a shoulder wound is much better. Ordinarily I wouldn't say this; but, you should go dumb yourself down with a less sophisticated movie that you can "get".

reply

It's just a movie, dude. Show us your M.D. and we will actually listen to what you say.

reply

I'm listening and agreeing with Shannon82.

reply

Thank you. 🌻

reply

You can go down on each other next.

reply

Here:
https://www.quora.com/How-long-can-a-person-who-has-been-shot-on-the-shoulder-survive-without-medical-help

Neff absolutely could have been killed from his wound. The same way that a writer can bend truth enough to make a shot to the centre mass non-lethal in their action movies, Billy Wilder can make a shot to the shoulder lethal in a noir.

reply

Yes, a shot to the shoulder can kill a person, if it hits or nicks the subclavian artery, one of the largest blood vessels in the body, and one that's so close to the heart that blood is pumped through it under high pressure.

A shot to the shoulder can be either a "flesh wound", or bleeding to death before the ambulance arrives.

https://www.kenhub.com/thumbor/cpOA3ELwo2-UCp9YChAKVnxMlSE=/fit-in/800x800/filters:watermark(/images/logo_url.png,-10,-10,0)/images/library/3011/kj0h3ReSIPYvozvqwZEbbA_Subclavian_artery-2.png

reply

It's been hours since he was shot. He's travelled to the office, and sat narrating the whole story to Keys on the Dictaphone. He's been bleeding the entire time. By the time he tries to walk out, he's too weak to stand for more than a few moments, and he collapses on the floor. He might very well expire from blood loss before the ambulance can get him to a hospital. There is absolutely nothing implausible about any of it. No, I'm not a medical doctor, but you have to be really stupid to believe that someone has to be a doctor to have such common knowledge. Any four-year-old knows you can bleed to death.

reply