MovieChat Forums > Bambi (1942) Discussion > Darkest Animated Film Ever?

Darkest Animated Film Ever?


If you go on the Pinocchio message boards, you get a lot of debate over whether or not Pinocchio is the darkest animated film ever. It didn't occur to me until today that Bambi is probably the darkest animated film ever (anime doesn't count, fyi). I don't know about the rest of you, but even with all the cute and charming characters, it used to depress the hell out of me when i was a kid! I rewatched it today, and I still have to agree it's probably the darkest animated children's film ever.

Reasons?

Bambi's mom of course, and the whole tense "don't go on the meadow" set-up, that's a notorious Disney-traumatizes-you-for-life scene. The whole hunter killing animals thing is pretty dark overall. When the quail freaks out and gets shot out of the sky while trying to escape has disturbed me since i was a kid. The forest fire caused by man. The buck trying to take Faline by force and the intense fight that follows. The scary looking dogs that look like they could be from the Resident Evil films. Bambi's distant relationship with his father.

What makes this all the more dark is that the film is going for realism, it's not a fantasy like Pinocchio or The Black Cauldron, or the other fantasies that get named. It's a story about man vs. nature, and man is the enemy.

Your guys' thoughts?

reply

[deleted]

There are a lot of darker animated films even if anime doesn't count. (And why wouldn't it count?!) Europeans have made very dark animated films from the beginning of cinema. Bambi might be the darkest animated film made in the US, though. It is a mixture of darkness and light, which makes it (unlike most Disney films) poetically beautiful. The only Disney film that I consider to be on the samel level with Bambi is the Lion King. Which, when you think about it, is quite similiar in many ways!

reply

Grave of the Fireflies

CB

Good Times, Noodle Salad

reply

Watership down is a far darker psychological animated animal film.


reply

[deleted]

My contenders for the darkest animated film are Plague Dogs and Felidae. Heavy Metal also has a pretty dark tone.

reply

[deleted]