MovieChat Forums > Hunter Schafer Discussion > Was she born male or female?

Was she born male or female?


5 minutes of googling and I can't get a straight answer for a rather simple question.

I get that she played a trannie.

Is the actress trans or a cis woman?

reply

He is a man that thinks he is a woman. Had all sorts of treatments done to "transition" including the so called "bottom surgery" as well getting implants.

reply

I don't know but that profile picture is very unflattering 😐

reply

She is trans. She was born a male and began treatments at a very young age (from what I recall reading). In the end, it comes down to the vocabulary used of "gender" or "sex" (since they are 2 different things no matter what anyone says). Biologically, Hunter was born with XY chromosomes making their "sex" male. Since chromosomes cannot be changed, biologically, Hunter is (and always will be) a male. Hunter's "gender" identity is female and they have undergone hormone treatments and surgery to change their physical characteristics, and they dress in a manner consistent with females. At the biological level, Hunter is still male.

reply

Okay, thank you. I have no problem if this person wants to be male or female. I have a problem with genital mutilation and castration of male children, but I won't get into that right now.

I just think it's ridiculous that a search engine is designed to obfuscate and hide information on whether or not a famous person was born male or female. Seriously, I checked site after site and they referred to her as a woman but I couldn't find one which called her "trans".

reply

In the community they decided, that everything before never happened. The person was always born a female (and the other name is called a dead name) and Google wants to respect their idea. I mean, as long you don't want to marry this person and want kids, I don't see many reasons what this info would bring to you? She decided to be like that on her own, so let it be. I mean, what does this info bring to you?
FYI: I also did my own research earlier, because I wasn't aware of this information. I was able to find it with the help of Google, but of course it does not state this directly. But not sure, if searches like is Robert Downey Jr a woman would have any other results.

reply

Huh? I'm LGBT. If we're supposed to be accepting of transgenderism, then we need honesty on the topic.

What does the info bring to me? It's just a stat like saying she was born in New Jersey and she's 25 years old. If she's lying about her age I don't really care about that either. But I expect accuracy from google when I look up information.

Frankly I don't care what celebrities want. I just want clean cold facts with no obfuscation.

Yeah, I accept her as a woman. But whether or not she's cisgender or trans shouldn't be a mystery.

reply

Hunter has always been a woman, that is what gender identity is about.

reply

If she was always a woman then what did she transition into?πŸ€ͺ

Sorry, if I look up a simple stat and want to know if she's cis or trans, it's just an objective fact which shouldn't be obscured by search engines like google.

If trans is a reality we should accept and respect, then it can't be a secret.

reply

The transition is just to conform her male body to her womanhood. Again always was a woman.

reply

You're confusing gender with biological sex. She was born with a male body. See, was that so difficult for you to admit?

Gender is a social construct. I just want the hard scientific facts, no social constructs.

reply

Sex is a social construct as well as trans right activist would tell you.

reply

I'll stick with science when it comes to biology.

If I wanna talk about social constructs then I'll listen to a "trans right activist".

reply

The science supports what I just said.

reply

No it doesn't and even "trans right activist" agree with me.

I'm talking about biological science. You're talking about social science. Two different animals. I just wanted to know his sex at birth and it's being hidden. Why? Is there something wrong with being trans?

reply

Not to dispute your statement, but do you believe that "gender" and "sex" are the same thing?

reply

No, they are separate.

reply

Just checking.

reply

Meh, don't expect any clarity on this issue from that one. 🀣

reply

"Hunter has always been a woman..."

That is absurd--pure delusion, fantasy. This person is a guy, a pathetic, mentally ill guy. Unfortunately, that's what gender identity is all about.

As for "sex" and "gender", any dictionary published before publishers were infected with wokeness has them as synonyms. Gender is simply another word for sex, nothing more. The present-day psycho-social spin on the word "gender" is an illiterate social construct.

reply

Seems, that children are better at spotting the difference here too.
Concordant decision: Male!

If you're unsure whether it's a wolf πŸΊβ€‹ or a dog πŸΆβ€‹ (husky, malamute or the like).
Ask a child!...they know it without a scientific research. β™₯

reply

Usually you can tell. But I googled images and in most of them she doesn't look trans.

I don't know if she has massive hands and feet but she looks like a biological woman in most her pics:

https://media.glamourmagazine.co.uk/photos/6410427b02016dd477efbfee/16:9/w_1920,h_1080,c_limit/HUNTER%20SCAFER%20FEATHER%20140323%20default-GettyImages-1392676820.jpg

reply

Usually I'm very bad at it. πŸ˜³β€‹
With pictures...I can see the difference immediately on videos or in real life.
Yah, hands and feet...and neck/throat are good features to tell.

And then there's something what's difficult to describe (what I don't see in pics).
Probably that's what children look at and if you ask them:
"I don't know why."...it's ok, relax πŸ«‚β€‹...it was just a question. ☺

reply

Hunter is one who really passes as a woman as they tend to say. You just can't tell with Hunter...

https://preview.redd.it/owcanl7740l51.jpg?auto=webp&s=fe74c623c0921e5d35ef0d33c46fbe358a066fb6

Look at that body, it is like the body of a high fashion female model.

reply

As said...(s)he doesn't pass as a female by children.

reply

TH CHILDREN THING IS WEIRD.🫀

reply

Well, I wouldn't call it "weird"...it's amazing.
It reminded to Mary Poppins, while other fairy tales follow a similar pattern.
A better contact to the unconscious can deliver info...so to speak.

Because the unconscious is completely autonomous, there is no way to know what information it will offer up, or what it will do with the material it is provided. So, relinquishing expectations for where the road of self-discovery might lead, I invited Mary Poppins to tea.
https://www.depthinsights.com/Depth-Insights-scholarly-ezine/e-zine-issue-5-fall-2013/a-spoonful-of-depth-brings-the-soul-to-life-the-psychology-of-mary-poppins-by-stacey-jill-zackin/

reply

GOT WEIRDER.🫀

reply

Apparently you've problems to face yourself.

reply

PROBABLY...MARY POPPINS SURE AS SHIT DOESN'T PLAY INTO THEM AT ALL THOUGH.

reply

You understood very well that Mary Poppins stands for something else.
And as already said, many fairy tales follow a similar pattern.

reply

🫀

reply

Guten Morgen, Kowalski! β™₯ ☼


Just teasing some socks with my ingenious bump. πŸ˜β€‹

reply

cute female with a cock

reply

As far as I know the "cock" was already removed.

And seems you need a 'spoonful' too (Mary Poppins).
Regarding your many short replies/bumps on Hunter's board. πŸ˜Žβ€‹

reply