MovieChat Forums > Brit Marling Discussion > I really didn't like Another Earth.

I really didn't like Another Earth.


I get the premise of it, but it just felt really flat to me. I think Brit is a good actress, but not as great of a screenwriter. The story was cliche' and I didn't really connect to the characters all that much.

The good Dale is in the lodge and he can’t leave. Write it in your diary. TWIN PEAKS

reply

This message has been deleted by an administrator

reply

This message has been deleted by an administrator

reply

cliche'?! ...anyway, I thought it was fantastic; the best film of last year.

reply

I think calling the OP an idiot is ridiculous. I personally really enjoyed Another Earth, but the OP clearly states why they didn't like the film in a relatively intelligent manner. Just because someone disagrees with you doesn't mean that person is stupid.

reply

It seems-to-Me like One of Those Films that I would get-more out-of after watching-It a 2nd or 3rd Time.

reply

The OP makes a completely false analysis of the film. To call this film cliche is completley wrong. It couldn't be considered cliche by any interpretation. Its the most totally original screenplay I've seen in years.

reply

yea, he could have cured cancer in that entire 10 seconds.

obnoxious twat

reply

so what? he didn't insult anyone, he just gave his opinion like a civilized person should and even avoided the typical condescending fan bashing(it's sad that's common enough to mention). whether he's wrong or right it doesn't deserve namecalling from some angry snob.

Who by the way didn't say anything to dispute it, it's quite clear which one of them was useless.

reply