MovieChat Forums > Melanie Discussion > "Brand New Key"

"Brand New Key"


is the most annoying song ever written and performed in the entire history of music, going all the way back to the stone age. If I hear it, and I can't escape or turn it off, it makes me want to claw my own eardrums out.

reply


We all have our own personal earworm hell, and she's not wielding the pitchfork for me.

reply

How long were you waiting for her to pass away so you could say that?

reply

Agreed. Horrible song. She did better stuff though.

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=hlp3wmE4bbI

reply

I agree it is a very annoying song, but does have a certain charm to it that kinda puts it into a "so bad it's good" category.

reply

This. It's annoyingly catchy for some reason.

reply

Yeah, sounds like bubblegum. But it was actually banned.

She was always surprised by the success — and controversy — of “Brand New Key,” which was banned by some radio stations. She said she wrote the song in 15 minutes and thought it was “cute, a kind of old ’30s tune.” It featured the lines:

Well, I’ve got a brand-new pair of roller skates

You’ve got a brand-new key

I think that we should get together

And try them on to see


But as she later acknowledged, “I guess a key and a lock have always been Freudian symbols and pretty obvious ones at that.” Indeed, writer-director Paul Thomas Anderson included “Brand New Key” in his 1997 porno industry film “Boogie Nights” for a seduction scene involving a character who never takes off her roller skates.

https://www.washingtonpost.com/obituaries/2024/01/25/melanie-singer-songwriter-woodstock-obituary-died/

reply

Impossible to feel bad when you sing along with it.

reply

Does it help that it's actually about sex?

reply