MovieChat Forums > Patrick Stewart Discussion > Captain James T. Kirk versus Captain Jea...

Captain James T. Kirk versus Captain Jean Luc-Picard.


Starship battle to the death.

Who wins?

reply

Picard in a starship battle, Kirk in a fistfight.

reply

I think I'd go with this.

reply


Kirk got more tang.

reply

Kirk. In every multiverse

reply

Picard is the greatest Captain the Enterprise ever had.

reply

Kirk hands down in every way shape & form.

reply

Picard is the greatest Captain the Enterprise ever including Mainline,Mirrorverse and Kelvin timelines.

reply

1701 D, 1701 E > 1701, 1701 A

reply

Sure, the later models are improved.

reply

Yes, I mean, I don't think Kirk would stand a chance against Picard, because Picard's ships are so much more advanced.

But if they'd get the same ships, I'd say whoever the writers wants to win wins.

reply

Okay. However, Kirk was always able to outwit more advanced alien crafts. I still think Kirk would beat Picard's ghey ass. 🤣

reply

lol sure... but only until Picard asks the 2 Klingon Bird of Prey to uncloak 😁

reply

Kelvinverse 1701 >>>>>1701 D, 1701 E > 1701, 1701 A

reply

hmm, what is this "Kelvinverse" you're talking about?😆

reply

the Kelvinverse is a much canon as the Mirrorverse Strange New Worlds and Lower Decks have confirmed this

reply

well, yes, the Enterprise visits new worlds in almost every episode, some of which are strange, and Lower Decks was a good episode of season 7. But 'Kelvinverse'.. 🤔

reply

The Kelvinverse Enterprise is a Top 5 Design The grown Enterprise J is the worst







https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=0fswRdvLgU0&t=16s

reply

Nah, I like my Enterprise with carpet.

reply

Quoting classical non fiction works and Shakespeare and engaging in diplomatic relations with non females? Picard.

Everything else, especially if females are involved? Kirk.

reply

Lmfao nailed it!

reply

Captain Sisko wins. 💖​

Kirk constantly risked his entire crew in pursuit of the hottest miniskirt. ☻
He deserved a little 'friendly fire'. 🤘🏽​

Boring Picard drinks tea best...Earl Grey. 🫖​

reply

Boring Picard drinks tea best...Earl Grey. 🫖​

Boring Picard ensured First Contact happened while conquering his personal bigotry against the borg.


Kirk constantly risked his entire crew in pursuit of the hottest miniskirt. ☻
He deserved a little 'friendly fire'. 🤘🏽​

Kirk matured and also conquered his bigotry against the Klingons and ensured peace for The Federation and Klingon Empire allowing Worf to be part of Starfleet his Alternate version conquered his recklessness as well and lived to his father George Kirk saving the Federation from Nero, Khan and Krall while doing it in the Enterprise and Franklin .

reply

Please, mark a quote.
Apart of that...disagree with you.

reply

Kirk and Picard ensured Starfleets continuing exploration and peace Star Trek 2009 ,First Contact and The Undiscoverd Country are the best entries in the franchise you know im right.

reply

Yah, I got it.
You're wrong...I would never trust a Capain as Kirk or Picard.
Self-absorbed.

reply

Self-absorbed.

both evolved based past there bigotry

reply

Lala...I just watch ski-jumping (females).
Great jump from Canada. 🇨🇦​
But probably Austria will make it...or Norway.

reply

Picard and Kirk are better than Sisko you just hate them because they had TV/Films recently typical Hockey is better than Ski Jumping

reply

Sisko is better than Kirk and Picard.
The movies didn't change that and I don't "hate them".
As said, Kirk constantly risked his entire crew in pursuit of the hottest miniskirt and Picard is a hypocrite. Didn't help both to get a redemption à la Dr. Faust, who had a bad character too.

Hockey is boring...with a few exceptions.
Canada or USA vs. Russia is interesting...and bloody! 🏑​ 🩸​ ☺

reply

Picard and it's not even close for me.

reply

Now you're close to me, sweety. 🤗​
Except of french accents. ☺

reply

I would choose Jean Luc.

reply

Only because you like how his name sounds.
This time no greetings from Señor Mo. ☻
Maybe for New Year. ☺

reply