Definitely Looks Like...
Sprague Graden from "Jericho", "Six Feet Under", an "Joan of Arcadia".
http://www.imdb.com/media/rm339385088/nm0337042
These two could definitely pull off playing sisters..
I've been watching New Girl with Zooey in it, and I don't see the resemblance...but that's just me!
I was gonna let you *beep* me, but I got my rag, and I know how you hate a mess