When I was in high school, my theatre teacher would bash his acting abilities all the time. I always found that appalling. I know a bad actor when I see one, and Leonardo in my opinion, definitely isn't one of them. He's one of my favorite actors. I think my theatre teacher was trippin.
He doesn't need to elaborate. Its clear his teacher is an assh0le and most likely just jealous. Leo is obviously one of the greatest actors to have ever lived.
Gilbert was along time ago and Leo was very young and I have to wonder if he would take on this great a challenge at this point in his career.
I have nothing against Leo at all. I rather like and certainly admire him.
But if someone feels his acting isn't always convincing after watching his more current movies, it wouldn't upset me.
I'm not convinced Shutter Island or Inception are marvels of acting intensity by him, although I do like the movies themselves. Same with The Departed. He does fine, but I don't get the feeling he really has to stretch (so to speak) his talent to perform the part. He's just Leo.
He was absolutely awesome in The Departed. You really felt his frustration and fear. I think this was one of his best performances. Wolf of Wall Street has to be at the top of the list though.
I did drama classes years ago and my teacher basically said the same thing about Mel Gibson. It was around the time Hamlet was released and the teacher almost gave himself a stroke ranting about how insulting it was for someone like Gibson to even think of touching Shakespeare. Even as a young person I could smell the sour grapes.