MovieChat Forums > General Discussion > What do you think about the low number o...

What do you think about the low number of grocery stores in the U.S?


Pros: The low number is why they can be so big. So when you get there the selection is usually massive by Western standards

Cons: Distances. Most homes are not within a 3-mile distance from their main store, and some are much further away than that.

I happen to live in a country with the opposite situation. We have more grocery stores per person than anyone else in the Western world, mostly because the population is very spread out. But since people are obviously not consuming more per capita here, the median store has a very limited selection compared to a 190.000 feet Walmart. They are almost always within a 5-minute drive from the home though.

Obviously these two are extremes so your ideal situation does not have to be anyone of these two.

But how happy are you with your situation?

Strange thing to think about, I know.

reply

I live in a US suburban town and have at least 4 different grocery stores within 5 minutes of my home. Not that it matters in my case, though. I use Instacart, a grocery delivery service.

reply

Oh. I completely forgot about those, even though I also use that here sometimes.

Among all delivery services combined will you say that 90%+ of all homes have this option?



reply

I'm not sure, but I'm leaning towards yes.

reply

I'm lazy so I mostly use Trader Joes, its small, on my way home, and most of it is ready to eat.

reply

TJ's prices are ime much lower for staples than any "normal" grocery store. My opinion may be biased, but I'd consider their quality higher, outside of perhaps farmers' markets.

Just recently, they were temporarily out of their unsweetened powdered cocoa, which is excellent, so I swung by a local Pavillions (big chain grocery store) to grab some. Their 9 oz tub of Hershey's was $8.99, compared to TJ's 9 oz for $3.69. I literally muttered "holy s#it!" and decided to wait a day or two for TJ's to get some out of principle.

I'm lazy, too, but don't see any connection to being a TJ's customer. They sell plenty of things that require some effort in the kitchen to render consumable. :D

reply

Trader Joe's prices are great, better than many supermarkets. Plus the quality is nonpareil, with a lot of low priced organics.

reply

Amen pal. I do like 90% of my shopping there, and only go to Smart & Final for paper towels & TP, and Ralph's or carnicerias for stuff like certain brands of mustard/hot sauce I prefer.

$9 for freakin' Hershey's. Gimmie a freakin' break!

reply

I go to Ralph's if I want something more exotic, like kim chee pot stickers or whatever. But for most items they're over priced.
.

reply

We have plenty of grocery stores where I am.

What I'm not happy about is the price fixing going on between the stores.

reply

Galen Weston can go to hell.

reply

Don't forget the "junior".

He inherited his wealth from daddy.

reply

Yes....the whole family can go to hell.

reply

I'm an exception, as I have three grocery stores within walking distance of where I live: Whole Foods, Trader Joe's, and Vons/Safeway. They are all less than half a mile from me. However, this is not typical in the USA, where most things are car-centric.

I loved living in Europe, where grocery stores were smaller, had a more neighborhood feel, and everything was truly within walking distance. The food was also generally better. Regardless, I think there are more than enough grocery stores here in the US/North America.

reply

What do you consider a low number?

There are at least eight grocery stores in my town alone. That's pretty typical. I live in the suburbs, not a big city.

My sister who lives down in rural North Carolina has four in her town.

reply

All kind of stores are permanently trying to expand, that's the core nature of capitalism.
For groceries there's the problem that consumers do not buy more stuff, meaning for every growing store there must be another one shrinking or a small one disappearing.
Since larger stores can offer lower prices there's a trend for ever larger stores which for groceries also means ever fewer stores.

However, bigger stores that eliminate smaller ones depend on customers being able to drive the longer distance, which for one requires a car and for two the amount of stuff people want to buy must give so much lower prices in the larger store that the time and money the longer drive costs is worth it.
In a country like the US, where over 50% of all people cannot even pay their rent on time, there aren't many options for groceries to grow and move further apart, simply because so many people can't reach the bigger ones.

Personally I don't really care because I'm fine either way.
I own a car and am retired, meaning I have the time and the option to reach the larger stores, but I live in the center of a medium sized city and I also have the money to pay the higher prices in smaller stores.
My wife and me drive once a week to a large grocery store outside the center and get a weekly supply, but anything that spoils quickly like fresh meat and vegetables we're getting on a daily basis from the small store around the corner, less than 2 minutes on foot away from our home.

reply

Where I live in St.Louis MO, on the Southside where I live, they have 4 grocery stores: Dierberg's, Schnuck's, WALMART, and ALDI and ALL are always busy, especially on Saturdays

reply

Plenty around me which allows comparison shopping and saving money. Plenty of huge supermarkets too.

reply