MovieChat Forums > General Discussion > (CLOSED) Rate this actor out of 10: Meli...

(CLOSED) Rate this actor out of 10: Melissa McCarthy

posted 9 months ago by samoanjoes (58524)
41 replies | jump to latest

I don't know why I keep putting myself into these tough situations. On one hand, I give her credit for doing drama and comedy, but on the other hand she has never made me laugh. 5/10 to be safe.

Final score - 5.95

Previous rounds:
Michael Keaton (7.9)
Matthew Broderick (6.6)
Jennifer Aniston (5.9)
Kevin Hart (4.8)
Melanie Griffith (5.4)
Chris Pratt (6.503)
Drew Barrymore (6.1)
Liv Tyler (3.9) (record low)
Dwayne "The Rock" Johnson (5.5)
Kim Basinger (6.3)
Ethan Hawke (7.97)
Matthew Modine (6.073)
Paul Walker (4.3)
Jennifer Lopez (4.760)
Tom Cruise (7.73)
Sandra Bullock (6.56)
Bill Pullman (6.1)
Uma Thurman (7.2)
Chris Rock (5.39)
Halle Berry (4.73)
Cameron Diaz (6.1)
Richard Gere (5.6)
Hugh Grant (6.37)
Adam Sandler (5.72)
Ryan Reynolds (5.6)
Gwyneth Paltrow (6.1)
Scarlett Johansson (7.1)
Pierce Brosnan (6.6)
Ben Affleck (5.95)
Whoopi Goldberg: (4.6)
Kirsten Dunst (7.2)
John C. Reilly (8.32) (record high)
Billy Zane (5.9)
Wallace Shawn (6.5)

[–] DMT (4483) 8 months ago

1/10 too fat to look at on screen...

[–] samoanjoes (58524) 8 months ago

Okay but as an actress though?

[–] DMT (4483) 8 months ago

actress need to be hot, I can go to walmart down the street an see someone hotter than this fatty 100 percent of the time, why would I watch a fat person on screen?!?

[–] StoneKeeper (28280) 8 months ago

Watch the movie Precious.

Then come back to me.

[–] DMT (4483) 8 months ago

That movie about the ham planet stealing chicken wings?!? I got better things to do with my time

[–] samoanjoes (58524) 8 months ago

"The softer the cushion, the sweeter the pushin'." - Spinal Tap

[–] WandererFromYs (2403) 8 months ago

Maybe a weird take, but I’ve thought she was cute ever since I saw her on Gilmore Girls, and I wish she would do more Drama, or more serious roles, because as a comedian, she horribly unfunny and annoying. She has to constantly ramble every time something funny is supposed to be happening, and she never says anything funny.

[–] samoanjoes (58524) 8 months ago

She was good in that movie with Richard E. Grant where she played that girl who was writing fraudulent letters. I just realized that I have trouble remembering the names of her movies.

[–] MonStar (13541) 8 months ago

She received an Oscar nomination for that... but in the SAME YEAR, won the Razzie for Worst Actress in the Happytime Murders movie.

[–] samoanjoes (58524) 8 months ago

I can't say I disagree with the Oscar nomination.

[–] ShogunofYonkers (78490) 8 months ago

Sort of amusing but no female Chris Farley

5/10

[–] samoanjoes (58524) 8 months ago

At least this one is still acting. Oh, snap.

[–] StoneKeeper (28280) 8 months ago

One of my wife’s favourite!

Me: 6.5/10

[–] overseas7 (5070) 8 months ago

Already closed but anyway: 6
I must be fair, I only know her performance in Girlmore girls.