MovieChat Forums > General Discussion > MovieChat Favorite Band (Round One - Par...

MovieChat Favorite Band (Round One - Part 3) (Closed)

posted a year ago by Boromir (10131)
36 replies | jump to latest

Based on the "Your Favorite Bands" discussion, we select MovieChat's Favorite Band. We begin with 64 bands in the elimination round.

Round One - Part 3 (out of 3) (Random draw)

1. The Doors vs. Grateful Dead

2. Guns And Roses vs. Public Enemy

3. Chicago vs. AC-DC

4. Supertramp vs. U2

5. Radiohead vs. Cypress Hill

6. Journey vs. The Beatles

7. The Cure vs. R.E.M

8. Carter Family vs. Cream

9. America vs. Led Zeppelin

10. Bon Jovi vs. The Ramones

You can still vote in Round 1 - Part 1
https://moviechat.org/general/GeneralDiscussion/65f06aa9992e9150801676de/MovieChat-Favorite-Band-Round-One-Part-1

And Round 1 - Part 2

https://moviechat.org/general/GeneralDiscussion/65f0d6ed2408cf050207afaf/MovieChat-Favorite-Band-Round-One-Part-2

[–] nyctc7 (44104) a year ago

Journey vs. The Beatles and America vs Led Zeppelin highlight the ridiculousness of this kind of contest. Previously, Kiss vs. Pink Floyd, Lynyrd Skynyrd vs. The Temptations, and a few more.

With all due respect

[–] Kowalski (79077) a year ago

I VOTED AMERICA...I LIKE THEM BETTER.

[–] Boromir (10131) a year ago

I am also fan of America but the LOTR songs of Led Zeppelin win it for me.
I also feel a sense of wasted potential of America. There first album was the best. They could have been bigger.

[–] Kowalski (79077) a year ago

I CAN'T ARGUE WITH THAT...AMERICA SEEMS TO HAVE FALLEN OFF THE WORLD IN THE 80S.

[–] Boromir (10131) a year ago

Still great band.

[–] Boromir (10131) a year ago

Why the bad mood nyctc7? Second time you complain about it.
Random draw is actually fairer than me dividing them according to my musical knowledge. It's not like I can rate them objectively.

The only important thing is who win at the end, if you can't beat any band, you don't deserve the win. So far Led Zeppelin defeat America 7-0, so what it's matter if they lose to them in round 1 or round 2?

[–] nyctc7 (44104) a year ago

Since we are talking about "favorite" as opposed to "who do you think is the greatest" maybe I see your point.

Still, it doesn't sit well.

[–] Boromir (10131) a year ago

I understand your perspective. Perhaps in the next draw, I'll ensure that the five winners with the most significant victories won't face each other. The same with the five winners with the smallest victory. No more than that, I don't want to give more advantage to bands that get easy draw in the first round.

[–] TimeTunnel (4769) a year ago

Hmmm...Hmmm. ☺

[–] StoneKeeper (28337) a year ago

STFU tunnel

[–] TimeTunnel (4769) a year ago

That was deep, Stoney. 🐰

[–] StoneKeeper (28337) a year ago

I know right 😆

[–] TimeTunnel (4769) a year ago

You think you're safe cause you're the incumbent here.
Don't try me, XXPO. 🐰

[–] StoneKeeper (28337) a year ago

I looked up the definition of incumbent and that I am not.

I looked up the definition of incuntinent and that you are.

Now shut up and go check my top 50

[–] TimeTunnel (4769) a year ago

Already checked your stupid OP (top 50).
Go ahead with your illustrious 'friends'.
And don't forget to pray. 😉

"What you gonna do when it comes for you." 🎵🎶

[–] StoneKeeper (28337) a year ago

Hey look, I’ll be straight up with you, I came at you out of the blue and was totally uncalled for but I found it funny since you literally didn’t say anything. You just made a sound with an emoji. You’re weird like that. And I have a twisted sense of humour. For all that’s worth, your a good sport to battle with.

[–] TimeTunnel (4769) a year ago

I feel truly honoured by your honesty. 🐰
Enjoy your Shogie.
https://www.worldofsweets.de/out/pictures/generated/product/1/540_340_75/schogetten-edel-alpenvollmilch-100g-no1-4708.jpg

[–] Kowalski (79077) a year ago

1. GRATEFUL DEAD.

2. PUBLIC ENEMY.

3. AC/DC.

4. SUPERTRAMP.

5. CYRESS HILL.

6. THE BEATLES.

7. THE CURE.

8. CREAM.

9. AMERICA.

10. THE RAMONES.

[–] nyctc7 (44104) a year ago

1. Grateful Dead (I like the Doors just fine but loyalty forces me to vote this way)
2. Guns And Roses
3. AC-DC
4. U2
5. Radiohead
6. The Beatles
7. R.E.M
8. Cream
9. Led Zeppelin
10. Bon Jovi

[–] tcrum (31863) a year ago

1. The Doors

2. Guns And Roses

3. Chicago

4. Supertramp

5. Radiohead

6. The Beatles

7. R.E.M

8. Cream

9. Led Zeppelin

10. Bon Jovi

[–] bobbydallas (8682) a year ago

01. The Doors
02. Public Enemy
03. AC-DC
04. Supertramp
05. Cypress Hill
06. The Beatles
07. R.E.M
08. Cream
09. Led Zeppelin
10. The Ramones

[–] StoneKeeper (28337) a year ago

1. The Doors

2. Guns And Roses

3. AC-DC

4. Supertramp

5. Cypress Hill

6. The Beatles

7. R.E.M

8. The Doors

9. Led Zeppelin

10. Bon Jovi

[–] MartyDeniro (4185) a year ago

1. The Doors
2. Guns And Roses
3. AC/DC
4. U2
5. Radiohead
6. The Beatles
7. The Cure
8. Cream
9. Led Zeppelin
10. Bon Jovi

[–] Satan2016 (26197) a year ago

What the fuck is this! Except for Radiohead and Cypress Hill, it's all Geezer music for 60+. Proper title is AARP Favorite Band!

[–] Boromir (10131) a year ago

Most people on the site are 35+

Anyway, it's based on real discussion.