MovieChat Forums > General Discussion > Art Should Take Precedence Over EVERYTHI...

Art Should Take Precedence Over EVERYTHING


There, I said it.

Anyone who disagrees has NO business on a film chat site. πŸ‘ŠπŸΏπŸ˜ 

reply

I agree with your sentiment but the reality is I have two kids, a wife and a mortgage and the electric company has never once paid itselfπŸ˜‰

reply

You agree? I thought you'd seen too much of real life to agree with that troll statement!

Because anyone who's seen the ugly side of real life knows that if you're ever trapped in a burning car, held hostage by a gunman, or diagnosed with a life-threatening illness, you will realize that the firemen, police, or doctor who could save your life matter at least as much as art. Art may make life worth the effort of living, but other things matter as well.

reply

I'm talking about the creation of art. Not whether artists are more valuable to society than doctors or other lifesavers (they're not).

Yes, my statement is a bit of trolling, but it's in reference to Disney's decision to censor The French Connection. They're putting other considerations ahead of *art* and that's what angers me, and it's why I talk about the primacy of art.

But I'm not *that* absurd. I don't think art is more important than more immediate concerns, like medicine and nutrition.

reply

Eh, I was playing along with the poster, he was obviously being a bit β€˜jokey’ as well.

I do agree though that art should generally be admired and I admire artists for the most part.

reply

Thanks Shogun. I think you understand where I'm coming from (and that I'm not always to be taken literally).

reply

Sure, I got it✌️

Your second sentence with the angry face punching emojies was a clear indicator that you were half goofing but I do agree art is important.

It’s why many of us are here…and also to discuss the best brand vacuum or worst asshole at work or whatever lol.

reply

This is what I told the gendarme after I pushed a kid in front of a tram because she was in my way while I was in a hurry to get to the Louvre. He didn't really agree, but I made him a nice little pastel caricature of himself and he skipped away.

reply

James Joyce pointed out about 100 years ago that "Style is everything."

reply

Imagine all the plot holes, when 'art' is more favored over logic & reasoning.

reply

You don't know how to appreciate art. Plot is nothing. I'm guessing you are not a fan of modern art--just flowers, fruit and faces for you, right?

reply

Plots and holes don't mix.

Yes, I'm okay with flowers, fruit, and faces; however, the audience needs to understand why a face is growing flowers out of it and why a pair of pares are there instead of breasts; there's a reason why the plot/story is more important.

If we're talking about an experimental film, that's another subject.


Ultimately, the looser the plot, the wider the hole.

reply

Who says that art is anathema to logic and reasoning?

A lot of great art incorporates logic and reasoning, unless it's surrealist.

reply

Who says that art is anathema to logic and reasoning?


You did when you used the term "art". Using 'art' in the manner that you chose is a bloated term [i.e., sorry, I cannot remember the proper term to explain what I mean to state].

reply

Art Carney?

reply

No.

Garfunkel.

reply