MovieChat Forums > General Discussion > What's with this recent trend of BAD MOV...

What's with this recent trend of BAD MOVIES being critically acclaimed?


I'm just going to reference ones I recently saw. Doctor Sleep, The Invisible Man, and The Night House.

I consider these all to be BAD.

1. Doctor Sleep

First of all, I think this can be blamed on Stephen King. But this story had NO REASON to be connected to The Shining. Right there, this was set up for failure. The only thing that connected it to the Shining Was that the main character was the kid....That's like making the movie "The Conjuring" as a direct sequel to the Rock Films....And the way that they're connected is that the main character is Robert Balboa, Rockey's only son.... Seriously, it was that unconnected. This would have done much better if it weren't connected, but even so, it still would have been bad. Also "Rose the Hat" is awful. So contrived. So obviously written to be some kind of horror Hot Topic Icon, like the next Jack Skellington....

2. The Invisible Man

WOW. It's painful enough how bad this film was. How they chose the worst actress for the Protagonist. How I was actively routing AGAINST the protagonist because of how dumb she was. But what's more painful than all of that was that society actually liked this movie.... I just could not stand it. First of all, in every scene where she was "framed", her reaction to it made me hate her so much. Her reaction to being accused of hitting the girl made her seem like a mental patient. When she was framed for slicing her sister's throat and she just continued to hold the knife in an upright position, just so everyone in the building could be 100 percent sure that she murdered her, I was so annoyed that it took me out of the film. The original version of this movie did not even have a female lead. They could have done this with a female lead if done correctly. Like, here's a novel idea: Make sure your female lead isn't annoying, ugly, and easy to hate. I will say that women are more inclined to enjoy this film. However, the overt feminist tones are so strong that it's cringeworthy for people who aren't into that stuff--And I'm fine with there being films just for females. But how about giving me a heads up so I don't watch it? Truly a dreadful movie that got a 93% on RT...

3. The Night House

Another high budget movie with an unlikable female lead. It also has an 86% on RT. That's the same rating as The Conjuring. According to critics, this movie is as good as the Conjuring. You know what that tells me? That films critics have no idea what they're doing. Maybe I should take up a career as a film critic if they're this inept at identifying good movies. Again, no problem with female leads. But when you make them insufferable, sarcastic, and rude, they kind of make the movie a drag. I get that she just suffered a death, which excuses a lot of her behavior. But at a certain point, it becomes unbearable. Also, they made her situation really weird. She and her husband live by themselves in a lakeview mansion, and he shoots himself. And she stays in her big lonely mansion right after. Doesn't go somewhere else. Doesn't stay with family. Nope. Her husband kills himself, and she just stays in that house with no one to comfort her. Oh, and within just a few days, she's back at her teaching job. Very weird behavior. Also, they were trying to pull off the whole "strong smart independent woman who don't need no man" blah blah blah overplayed nonsense that we're tired of. Oh, also, throughout the movie there's this big buildup with clues that show the husband was a serial killer. And throughout, she finds more and more clues, setting up a big reveal...And then the big reveal ruins everything. The reveal was that her husband was murdering all these people because some supernatural entity was telling him to murder his wife. So instead he found people who looked like his wife and killed them instead. That's it. That's the whole thing. It was just bad. Anti-climatic and just really horrible.

Does anyone else see this trend of really bad movies getting critical acclaim? I do and it's really making me want to just indulge in the classics for a while...

reply

something that might be worth a mention is that it's not only critics that seem to like these movies.

all of them seem to be pretty widely liked by the people that saw them.

on letterboxd, they have the following ratings:

dr sleep 3.4
the night house 3.5
the invisible man 3.6

those are all pretty positive numbers for horror films.

if you don't dig them, i'm not gonna argue with you. you are entitled to your preferences.

but you are not the movie police, or the final authority on the goodness of any of those movies.

like i said above, i really liked two of them a lot. i really liked night house in particular, gave it a 4/5, & have it ranked as my 13th favourite film of the year so far, of the 101 i've seen.

reply

I liked Doctor Sleep but I didn't love it. The kind of film I watch once and have no desire to see again. Whereas The Shining is a film I watch at least once a year.
I tried watching The Invisible Man but stopped after about 45 minutes.

I think it's been going on for a while in SF. Not including the Star Wars, Star Trek and superhero films.

Moon (2009)
District 9 (2009)
Arrival (2016)
Mad Max Fury Road (2015)
Black Runner 2049 (2017)

Arrival, District 9 and Mad Max received Best Picture nominations. I would have given them Razzie nominations instead.

reply