Actors whose charisma is mistaken for bad acting
Parallel thread to this one:
https://moviechat.org/general/General-Discussion/5e3582ef12166028cb00bbaa/Actors-whos-carisma-is-mistaken-for-good-acting
This case, actors who are considered as charismatic but unable to act, but that given the chance, they happen to be quite good actors (or actresses).
- John Wayne, amazing as the hidden villain of the story in The Searchers (1956).