MovieChat Forums > General Discussion > I’m not buying Tom Hanks as Mr Rodgers

I’m not buying Tom Hanks as Mr Rodgers


He has the look down but his voice is way too deep. Rodgers has a very soft, feminine voice.

reply

See this instead https://www.imdb.com/title/tt7681902/

Good documentary. I am too old to have grown up with Mr. Rogers and while I came away from the film mostly liking him, I didn't care for his character on his show. Too effeminate. I want to say to him https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=7nqcgUDoV_M or http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=fQAwRpRe9F4&t=0m25s

reply

Not sure why this is in the general? Theres a board for this movie, right?

reply

I don't expect an exact duplicate of Mr Rogers - just the essence of him. Close enough in my book.

reply

This was pretty much my thoughts while watching the trailer.

reply

I saw the trailer and immediately hated the film on sight.

Tom Hanks is completely miscast, for sure. And a vibe I got from the trailer was that the movie was just going to dumb Mr. Rogers down into this one dimensional "nice guy" who talks about fee-fees all the time. This is not why the show was good or popular. The whole point of the show was to teach kids to not grow up to be the typical douchenozzle who just hops in and out of his house without getting to know his neighbors and the people who helped make it functional (like the local butcher, mailman, etc.).

reply

I like the casting of Hank. Who'd you cast?

reply

How can people fall for that?

reply

Ha, I agree. I think its ridiculous that Hanks is playing him. Its impossible to capture Rodgers through acting. He was just different. If you never knew what he was about and saw the show you would think he was creepy to be honest.

reply

I think he'll do just fine.

reply