MovieChat Forums > General Discussion > Rate a Director #6: Special Combo Friday

Rate a Director #6: Special Combo Friday


In order to try to please the most people, this week Im making a combo special.

We had: Aronofsky, Boyle, Scott, Gilliam and Nolan.

This week:

David Fincher:

1995 Seven 8.5
1997 The Game 8
1999 Fight Club 10
2002 Panic Room 6.5
2007 Zodiac 6.5
2008 The Curious Case of Benjamin Button 7
2010 The Social Network 6
2014 Gone Girl 8





BONUS director: Blake Edward :

The Party (1968) : 8/10
Blind Date : 6.5/10

reply

Se7en 8
Zodiac 6
Fight Club 8
Gone Girl 7

Never seen the others

reply

Finally, one where I've seen them all!

1995 Seven 7
1997 The Game 8
1999 Fight Club 8
2002 Panic Room 6
2007 Zodiac 7
2008 The Curious Case of Benjamin Button 7
2010 The Social Network 7
2014 Gone Girl 8

Blake Edwards
The Party (1968): 7
Blind Date (1987): 6.5

and Ive also seen

Breakfast at Tiffany's (1961): 8
The Pink Panther (1963): 8
Revenge of the Pink Panther (1978): 7
Skin Deep (1989): 7
Switch (1991): 7


reply

Good job Fletch!!

reply

Oh, I just somehow knew Fincher's going to be next. I'm a magician! (to quote Phil the Alien, a movie no one's seen. I think lol)

Alien 3 (1992) It's an Alien movie, sort off. Didn't care for it much.
Sesevenen (1995) I love it. Disturbing, in a good way. Plus, Gwyneth Paltrow get's [spoilered].
Fight Club (1999) I used to love it, the last time I watched it I was over it TBH. Still, a pretty cool movie, and surprisingly funny. Plus, Jaret Leto gets [spoilered].
Panic Room (2002) A decent thriller. I liked it.
Zodiac (2007) Eeeeh... It was alright. I bit disappointing maybe.
The Curious Case of Benjamin Button (2008) Not a fan.
The Social Network (2010) Have not seen.
The Girl with the Dragon Tattoo (2011) A faithful adaptation to the book, and a alright movie, not my favourite though.
Gone Girl (2014) I liked it a lot.
World War Z 2 (TBD) ??? LOL

Blake Edward:

Victor Victoria (1982) I saw it thanks to the ATM club (RIP in peace). I liked it.

reply

You read me like an open book!

WhatS' the ATM club?


reply

It's like I have ESPN or something!

Remember that movie discussion club we had for a while? That's ATM. It died a lonely, silent death (it was pretty much Dewey and me at the end there lol).

reply

Ahhh yeah! Now I remember.

RIP indeed

reply

One of my favorite directors.

1. Seven (10/10)
2. Fight Club (9/10)
3. Gone Girl (9/10)
4. The Girl with the Dragon Tattoo (8/10)
5. The Curious Case of Benjamin Button (8/10)
6. Panic Room (8/10)
7. The Social Network (7/10)
8. Alien 3 (7/10)
9. Zodiac (7/10)
10. The Game (6/10)

reply

me too!

reply

❤️️
2010 The Social Network 5/10
1995 Sev7en 9/10
that's it.

reply

Whhhat!?!?

So nothing from Blake Edward?

That was my surprise for you darn it!!

reply

❤️️

I confess that I didn't really notice that Bonus Director. I guess I didn't bother because I was once again sort of disappointed that you don't seem to be familiar with any who directed films that I love.
Sorry. I am at least familiar with Blake Edward's work.
Let me start with two really good TV shows....
Mr. Lucky
Peter Gunn
Both characters are Cool Cats!

My fave films?
All of the Pink Panther films are fun.
Victor Victoria is the BEST!
10. Who can forget Dudley Moore in that? (probably all of the guys here. After all, Bo Derek was the 10 in that.

reply

Yeah, I can understand your disappointment because When I read your answer “that’s it” I was like: “I failed to please her :(“

Haha, anyways, I think I found a middle ground for us.

As you can see, Fincher is loved by the general public though. You should watch more from him.

reply

❤️️
Oh, I can learn from these weekly threads. I'm not opposed to trying new things. I have looked at some of the movie descriptions from the various lists of films. A few look sort of interesting. I put them on my never ending watch list. All I can say is that we had better have a long cold winter. I have much to learn!
I do wish you would give Hitchcock a try. Those two films you saw are pitiful examples of his long list of truly good films!
Try
Shadow of a Doubt
Strangers on a Train,
Rope
Notorious
Life Boat
North By Northwest
The Man Who Knew Too Much
Rear Window
The Birds
Rebecca
Psycho

If you can't try Hitchcock, try Kubrick. I just watched Lolita! James Mason was fantastic, as always!

reply

WHen I'll watch more Hitchcock you'll be the first to know. I might even boost him up higher on my (also) never ending list.

North by Northwest looks especially interesting.

reply

❤️️
LOL! I can understand that long watch list.

reply

David Fincher:
1992 Alien 3 6/10
1995 Seven 9/10
1997 The Game 9/10
1999 Fight Club 8/10
2002 Panic Room 8/10
2007 Zodiac 7/10
2008 The Curious Case of Benjamin Button 9/10
2010 The Social Network 9/10
2011 The Girl with the Dragon Tattoo 9/10
2014 Gone Girl 9/10

Blake Edwards:
1962 Days of Wine and Roses 8/10
1968 The Party 4/10
1979 10 7/10
1982 Victor Victoria 9/10

reply

Seven 8.5
Fight Club 7
Panic Room 7
Zodiac 8
Gone Girl 6.5

reply

David Fincher -
Se7en - 8.5
Panic Room - 7

Blake Edwards -
Switch - 4
Victor Victoria - 7
10 - 9
The Great Race - 6
A Shot In the Dark - 8
The Pink Panther - 7
Breakfast at Tiffany's - 8.5
Operation Petticoat - 6.5

reply