MovieChat Forums > General Discussion > Whale..... goodbye!

Whale..... goodbye!


For exactly 3 days I thought this was the best film site since imdb. Especially since the site creators had painstakingly imported all the imdb discussions (amazing), it seemed like moviechat would pick up right where imdb left off.

And it did. With the trolls.

What film forum has 10x more posts in the Donald Trump forum than all movies put together? A forum that has nothing to do with movies but serves as a festering hole for people with nothing better to do than hate. People on both sides of the political bickering, how bout taking this to an actual political discussion board if you think you can hold your own. Leave moviechat to those who want to, I dunno, chat movies? (And I mean actual movie talk, not just using a movie as an excuse to spew random hatred)

The Trump board--which is constantly trending--only serves to wind people up, and unable to contain themselves they spread their infection to other forums. I raised this concern with the mods, and while they agreed that political bickering is a big problem, there's not much they can do. I suggested taking down the Trump board as it has nothing to do with actual movies. But we'll see.

Anyway gang, I enjoyed the 3 or 4 film-related discussions I had here. Still looking for a comprehensive film board where I can talk shop with like minded individuals about the art & architecture of cinema. I work in the film industry and rely on intelligent opinions to help me get the job done. Any suggestions, let me know. Til then... See you at the party Richter.

EDIT: best candidate so far is tmdb.org Dedicated to movies only, and troll levels seem low so far.

reply

I am bumping this to show the prevalence of trolls on this site, and their deleterious effect on MC posters.

reply

Come on. Give Moviechat another chance!

reply

I’m still here. You’re not.

reply

Me too, but it gets harder to stay. I really liked this site about the first year. It has gradually changed to something else. I think that other site looks better all the time. It may be the Wild West over there, but you know what to expect.

reply

What other site, mate?

reply

I see that you are new here. Welcome to MovieChat.
Let's wait on the Mate. Let's see if we might be potential friends first. You do seem friendly enough.
There are many sites out there. Take your pick. This site is actually fairly good. You may have found your home away from IMDb right here. Enjoy.

reply

Didn't mean to unduly imply intimacy, just being friendly.

Cheers!

reply

No worries....... mate.

reply

welcome to you and ignore the negative Nellie.

reply

But the Negative Nellie's are the more interesting ones, mate.

And thank you!

reply

You can have them. lol

reply

You see, there was a dreadful troll here who pretended to be Romanian whose salutatorians to other posters was “Mate,” and that created bad subsequent repercussions. Now you know, Cobber.

reply

How unruly!

Much obliged for the backstory on this rambunctious whipper snapper, chum. I'll keep my eyes peeled for any suspicious folk throwing words of endearment around frivolously, mate.

reply

Stop being a whiny little bitch!

reply

Directed at whom, and apropos of what?

reply

The best suggestion is to Report some threads a troll has posted. If you find yourself trying to push against the ocean, all you can do is click on Ignore.

reply

I think it's entirely possible for someone to set the tone they choose, bring up thoughtful subjects and avoid inflammatory ones, and draw in people who are intelligent and polite. Mostly it's about how you (or I) go about our business.
If an "idiot" wants to pick a fight over Jeanette Nolan's performance in The Searchers, no one's going to take that person seriously, and they will disappear.

And the more WE encourage good Movie Chat around here, the better things will get.
Personally, I compartmentalize my Political Persona and my Entertainment Persona. I get torqued off at Rabid Repubs but I try not to have that carry over onto non-political threads.

reply

I agree, at least on imdb there were discussions and you werent reminded of the obama board every minute,

and if you wanted in on a tv series, you could post on the board without everyone knowing you're trending, felt more private

trending film boards depersonalizes the experience, you got to feel like you're getting something out of it for being on the board and not just have it trend, really gay if you ask me, this isnt twitter

reply

Is Twitter gay?

reply

Trending section was one of the only genius moves ive seen from jim. It has gone a long way towards making the discussion boards relevant.

reply

my point is the trending doesn't work if it is distracting to people who could'nt care less about politics, it's an entertainment site

trolls or no trolls, the trending is distracting and works better on social media site

reply

Nine tenths of the trending is entertainment.

reply

Actually...14 out of 15 are entertainment👍

reply

not genius

reply

You are a really bad one to judge😂

reply

this should be an escape from real-world events to those who want to choose to, not be reminded of crap anyone who doesn't have a life and doesn't really need to care about unless you really are that bored.

reply

???

reply