I would agree with your Mad Max and Empire Strikes Back choices. As for LOTR, The Fellowship is more literarily wonderful than its sequels, but I think that's due to its advantage of being the first. It introduced us to a world about which we had read literally volumes, but had never seen. I think the two sequles were equally well-crafted films, and done with every bit as much love as the first, in sad contrast to The Hobbit monstrously. The chapter, The Battle of the Pellinor Fields, in TROTK, where the Rohirim mow down the Orcs with their onrushing steeds, is as thrilling and satisfying a scene as any other to be found in the series.
Turning to Raiders: well the name Indiana Jones was never part of the title until they released the box set collection, which I own, and was saddened to see the total had by some means transformed to Indiana Jones and the Raiders of the Lost Arc--on the DVD case. Play the actual disc, and that ain't the title. To me, Raiders is head, shoulders and belly-button above the other Indy movies.
To contribute, rather than comment: Hellboy: The Golden Army is a 'way better movie than Hellboy, which is a good movie but not nearly as good as its sequel.
reply
share