MovieChat Forums > Politics > do we even NEED government?

do we even NEED government?


we all whine and huff about everything, yet the government provides many things we use, and makes decisions we may not like for the greater good.

could we self manage?
if so, where is that working in today's current world that serves as a functioning model of that?

reply

Only solution is to give more power at local levels (less authority from central government). See Switzerland for example.

No central government means no big spending, no highways, no army, no defense, any bigger country can invade you.

reply

your last line is the big picture problem. maybe if all the earth got along.... yet turns out ONLY the governments want to war... the people rarely do.

reply

Sometimes I think it would be good if The Purge was a real thing.

reply

we do need to PURGE unlimited terms of service.... :D

reply

We need some basics, but we don't need people lining their pockets and those of their relatives and friends.

reply

yeah true. but there is always corroption somewhere in huge things.

I have friends that complain about government, not needing it, and I'm lik, "really?? Do you have electricity? Running water? Ever driven on any road ever? In a car that passed a bajillion safety requirments to keep you alive?" they seem to have zero clue how well their world has been crafted by a governing group.

and I hate politics

reply

Anyone who doesn't think we need some form of government needs to drive in a poorly designed parking lot and see what happens ( :

reply

and people werent meant to become rich being civil servants.

reply

Not only do we need a government, but if we magically made the government disappear, a new government would immediately take its place. I believe governments are an emergent property of societies. If you get enough people together and try organizing to accomplish something, a structure will form and that will be the birth of a new government.

reply

yeah, I agree with this.

everyone saying we don't need one, then when trying with out, we need some kind of order and control, and it happens any way.

reply

yes need government but people need to stop acting like there two choices when there's three RFK Jr should be president but others prefer not to vote with there brain.

reply

Government is what happens when any number of people decides to live together as a group, a community. You can't have people in the group literally doing anything they want, so there have to be rules. There have to be consequences for breaking rules, there have to be people who decide whether someone actually broke the rules or not, etc. The only way to not need government is for people to decide for themselves that they're going to be good and upstanding and never ever fuck over any of their neighbors, ever, period. Good luck with that.

reply