MovieChat Forums > Politics > Afghanistan has Fallen

Afghanistan has Fallen


https://apnews.com/article/afghanistan-taliban-kabul-bagram-e1ed33fe0c665ee67ba132c51b8e32a5

When asked for comment: Dementia Joe said "C'mon man!"

No word yet if NATO or the UN will liberate the Afghani peoples.

stayed tuned...

reply

These loons wouldn't have done it with trump in the white house, Dementia Joe is a soft touch, he's not respected.

reply

Why’s anyone surprised.

Benghazi 2.0.

reply

From your link:

"For years, the U.S. sought an exit from Afghanistan. Then-President Donald Trump signed a deal with the Taliban in February 2020 that limited direct military action against the insurgents. That allowed the fighters to gather strength and move quickly to seize key areas when President Joe Biden announced his plans to withdraw all American forces by the end of this month."

Once again, Trump started a mess!

reply

Once again you are wrong. The drawdown began with OBAMA! Trump continued, but not completely.
Now Biden is at full throttle! BTW, when Obama began withdrawing in 2011 he left all the military equipment behind. Guess who’s taking advantage of our armament?

”Biden forges ahead where Trump and Obama failed on infrastructure and Afghanistan”

”His huge gamble on more than $4.5 trillion in infrastructure spending and an exit from America's longest war, *which threatens to trigger a foreign policy disaster*, are both unfolding in a dramatic August that could define his presidency. Alongside these twin historic pushes, the story of Biden's administration is also being shaped by *a resurgence of the pandemic that he thought he had beaten* and is deepening the national political estrangement he vowed to heal.”

https://www.cnn.com/2021/08/12/politics/joe-biden-donald-trump-barack-obama-afghanistan-infrastructure/index.html


”Drawdown of US embassy in Kabul is under discussion, sources say, as Taliban makes rapid gains in Afghanistan”

https://www.cnn.com/2021/08/10/politics/embassy-kabul-drawdown/index.html

reply

So Dementia Joe just blindly follows whatever Trump says or does? He is the puppet president, he gets all the blame. Isn't how that works?

reply

Trump made the Taliban stronger. Were you willing to send tens of thousands of American soldiers there to regain the loss territory?

reply

No, Obama made the Taliban stronger. Go back in history. You can’t begin with Trump.

From leftist news sources:

https://www.nbcnews.com/storyline/president-obama-the-legacy/obama-s-afghanistan-legacy-what-trump-faces-america-s-longest-n708331


”Obama’s Winning Move: Negotiate with the Taliban”

https://www.huffpost.com/entry/obamas-winning-move-negot_b_946042


”In his speech Senator Obama declared that “America can’t [win in Afghanistan] alone... The Afghan people need our troops and your troops; our support and your support to defeat the Taliban and al Qaeda, to develop their economy, and to help them rebuild their nation. We have too much at stake to turn back now.”

The linkage between al-Qa’eda and the Taliban has been made so often since 2001 that the terms have become almost interchangeable, as if they represent the same overall movement or phenomenon. Indeed, the Taliban regime that ruled Afghanistan from 1996 through 2001 harbored and supported Osama bin Laden and al-Qa’eda, enabling the attacks of September 11.

But their cooperation then (and now) does not mean they can be fought along similar lines. Obama’s close association of the two groups, WHICH MIRRORS THE BUSH ADMINISTRATION POLICY,simplifies a far more complex reality, against which a strategy based primarily on force and violence will likely fail.“


Again from the Huff Post:

https://www.huffpost.com/entry/obama-and-the-taliban_b_114900

reply

You have to go back further. Bush 2 started two wars. The complaint was that he should have focused only on Afghanistan.

9/11 likely happened because of anger when Americans were in Saudi Arabia and the war against Iraq started by Bush 1. The U.S. messy Middle East policy goes back further. Another reason to develop green energy instead of relying on oil.

More recently, there is plenty of blame for all the recent administrations. Afghan government was a corrupt U.S. puppet which most people didn't support. The U.S. also supported warlords which had committed human rights violations. Afghan was always going to be a quagmire since the Taliban could wait for the U.S. to leave and then retake the country.

Plan should have been to remain stationed there. But, Trump wanted to meet with as many tyrannical leaders as he could so he invited the Taliban to dinner at Camp David. Trump promised to leave which emboldened the Taliban.

You're afraid to answer about sending in U.S. troops to escalate a war in order to regain territory lost when Trump started pulling troops out of the region. American people would never support that.

Do you at least support bringing Afghans who helped the U.S. here or are you so hateful that you want them to die?

reply

” 9/11 likely happened because of anger when Americans were in Saudi Arabia and the war against Iraq started by Bush.”

Am I reading you correctly? Are you stating 9/11 occurred because Bush started a war against Iraq? Explain please how the timeline works. 9/11 happened on September 11, 2001 and the war against Iraq began on March 19, 2003…18 months after 9/11

Also, how anyone can blame Bush for 9/11 is beyond reason. You can blame him for many other things, but not 9/11. You could blame Bill Clinton if you want to get technical. He was given Osama on a silver platter after the ‘93 bombing of the WTC. He chose not to due to the collateral damage of 300 villagers. So, instead we gave up over 3,000 souls. Thank God we didn’t fight WW2 in the same manner. We would have lost! Just think if Clinton had taken the offer there wouldn’t have been a 9/11 and an Iraq War. 🤷🏼‍♀️

”Bill Clinton, Hours Before 9/11 Attacks: 'I Could Have Killed' Osama bin Laden”

“I nearly got him. And I could have killed him, but I would have had to destroy a little town called Kandahar in Afghanistan and kill 300 innocent women and children, and then I would have been no better than him.

“And so I didn’t do it.”

Hours after Clinton spoke, a hijacked Boeing 767 slammed into the north tower of New York City’s World Trade Center. A second plane struck the south tower 18 minutes later. Other planes crashed in Washington, D.C., and western Pennsylvania. The attacks, organized by bin Laden, killed more than 3,000 people.“


reply

The 1991 war against Iraq aka: Gulf War started by Bush 1. Bush 2 was upset that Hussein insulted his daddy, too.

Lazy Bush 2 spent plenty of time on vacation instead of being president. I always blamed his laziness on 9/11 along with decades long U.S. bad policy throughout the Mid-East.

Osama didn't create the plan. He approved it. Taking him out would change nothing since a new leader would have approved it.

Our allies, the Saudis knew Osama's location!

Like I wrote, plenty of blame for BOTH political parties.

Clinton's speech was irrelevant. He messed up by backing the wrong leader in Afghanistan. There was a pro-democracy leader who we should have supported, but didn't until it was too late.

But, I blame the Soviets most of all. Their meddling and invasion of Afghanistan ignited much of the terrorism.

reply

Dementia Joe just came out of hiding to say that he agrees with Trump, that this war should be over, he quickly went back on vacation at Camp David.

reply

You're seriously asking Komrade Keelai if something is Trump's fault? According to that reprobate, Trump caused the extinction of the dinosaurs.

reply

I blame George W Bush and company for sending troops there in the first place. Complete bloody madness.

reply

Taliban: "Death to America!"
CNN: "They seem friendly"
Patriots: "We love America!"
CNN: "Domestic terrorists!"

reply

This is the result of Cheney's War on Terror. There is no simple fix. Either we let their own people figure it out, or we stay there indefinitely. Both can have consequences.

Anyone blaming Biden or Trump for it is being a partisan ideologue.

reply

And if there was no Cheney's war on terror, people would blame him and Bush too, you cant win.

I wonder when people will learn that you cant fix the Middle East. They have been like that for over 2000 years.

reply

There's no way in hell a VP gets blamed for 9/11.

Bush maybe, but the answer is getting Bin Laden, not a War on Terror.

With Bin Laden gone, the blames cease.

But also, the Bush Doctrine against the Taliban becomes obsolete. That's no good for the MIC.

This whole thing is to get the war machines rolling again so the contractors can get back to making wads of cash.

reply

Biden has his Katrina 6 months in...Lame Duck.

Here comes Kamala.

reply