MovieChat Forums > Politics > Black woman in prison while woman free f...

Black woman in prison while woman free for same crime


Actually, the white woman stole more money and had a long record unlike the black woman.

The same Ohio Court; two white judges; one day a part.

"The white woman committed more crimes, over a longer period of time. She stole more money than the Black woman. She had 21 more charges and cost taxpayers six times more money. She was facing 60 years in prison while the Black woman’s maximum sentence was three years. Yet the Black woman received more prison time than prosecutors wanted her to spend in jail.

Unlike Bosworth (white woman), Gallagher (black woman) pleaded guilty. Unlike Bosworth, Hopkins was only charged with one count of theft in office. Unlike Bosworth, Hopkins had already found a new job, completed an in-patient program for her gambling addiction and had promised to repay the money she stole.

Nationwide, Black people convicted of crimes received 20 percent longer sentences than similarly situated whites who commit the same offenses, according to the U.S. Sentencing Commission. In Ohio, the state’s Black residents are imprisoned at 6 times the rate of Ohio’s white residents, according to the Sentencing Project. In 1999, a report from the Commission on Racial Fairness found that Black Ohioans are sentenced to prison at grossly disproportionate rates compared to their white counterparts."
https://www.yahoo.com/lifestyle/ohio-court-sentences-black-woman-193000949.html

This is called institutional and systemic racism.

reply

This story is an excellent example of bias in news reporting. The author had an agenda to push, and left out pertinent information from the story.

From here: https://www.cleveland.com/court-justice/2021/08/former-maple-heights-high-school-secretary-sentenced-to-prison-for-stealing-40k-from-school.html

Cuyahoga County Common Pleas Court Judge Rick Bell told 51-year-old Karla Hopkins that she compounded her theft by liquidating her public employee pension shortly after the district discovered the theft. The move prevented the state from seizing the money to pay back the district.

...

Bell quickly quizzed Hopkins about her pension and how much money she took out after her arrest. She eventually said she took all of it out.

Ohio law requires any money left in the public pension account of someone convicted of theft in office to go toward restitution. Hopkins told Bell that she did not know about the law and that she took the money out to pay her bills because she lost her job.

“You knew that you had stolen money,” Bell said. “You didn’t use that money to pay restitution that you knew you owed.”

Bell told Hopkins that she compounded her situation by taking money out of her account.

...

Debbie Bosworth, a clerk in the village’s utilities and building departments, pleaded no contest to 22 counts, including third-degree felony theft in office charges. She admitted to stealing more than $20,000 a year as residents paid their water bills in cash. Bosworth resigned from the village shortly after village officials caught her in 2019 and began paying back the stolen money before she was charged. She also kept her pension intact and allowed prosecutors to seize more than $200,000.


It can be argued that paying back the money shouldn't affect the sentence, but the reporter in your story left that fact out completely, not allowing their readers to use that information in making up their minds.

Just another dishonest leftist pushing an agenda. This is why people don't trust the news anymore.

reply

No surprise that you would support racism considering your previous racist comments.

Your link doesn't say anything differently from mine.

reply

No surprise you're an illiterate race pimp

reply

You're projecting, again. Obviously, you have nothing intelligent to add.

reply

If only your mom had to the foresight to know opening her legs wouldn't add anything intelligent to the world either

reply

Silly Randal, Trix are for kids. Next time use the same tactics he uses by accusing first if they don't agree with the narrative or view.

reply

racist racist racist racist racist racist racist racist racist

reply

I know you're a racist. Now, we both agree.

reply

you're another liberal that uses minorites to win votes, remember what lbj said?

shame on you

reply

"Your link doesn't say anything differently from mine."

Your link:

Hopkins told Bell that she emptied her pension — she didn’t know how much was in it but said, after taxes, she received about $20,000 — to pay her bills after the school fired her.


No mention about emptying her pension was against the law, and that was the reason the judge gave for giving her time.

My link:

Bell quickly quizzed Hopkins about her pension and how much money she took out after her arrest. She eventually said she took all of it out.

Ohio law requires any money left in the public pension account of someone convicted of theft in office to go toward restitution. Hopkins told Bell that she did not know about the law and that she took the money out to pay her bills because she lost her job.

“You knew that you had stolen money,” Bell said. “You didn’t use that money to pay restitution that you knew you owed.”

Bell told Hopkins that she compounded her situation by taking money out of her account.


Clearly explains why Hopkins was sentenced to the time she got.

Your link:

Unlike Bosworth, Hopkins had already found a new job, completed an in-patient program for her gambling addiction and had promised to repay the money she stole.


Using the phrase, "Unlike Bosworth" your biased reporter is insinuating that Bosworth didn't pay the money back.

My link:

Bosworth resigned from the village shortly after village officials caught her in 2019 and began paying back the stolen money before she was charged. She also kept her pension intact and allowed prosecutors to seize more than $200,000.


Clearly explains that Bosworth began paying back the stolen money, and then her intact pension was used to pay it back also.


How retarded do you have to be not to see the difference?

This reporter writes this biased bullshit because they know there are idiots out there like you who will gulp it down without questioning anything.

reply

Your post proves you're racist as well as illiterate and stupid since your own link is criticizing the racism, too!

Only a vile racist like yourself who believes a white woman repeatedly stealing over a period of 20 years ($20k ea. yr.) for a total of $250,000 committed a lesser crime than a recently unemployed, formerly mentally-ill black woman stealing one time out of economic desperation ($40k) who has since rehabilitated herself with therapy, a new job and repaying $5k.

reply

"since your own link is criticizing the racism, too!"

Really? The article I posted doesn't mention the races of the two women. So how is it criticizing the racism?

I'll be waiting for your explanation.

"Only a vile racist like yourself who believes a white woman repeatedly stealing over a period of 20 years ($20k ea. yr.) for a total of $250,000 committed a lesser crime than a recently unemployed, formerly mentally-ill black woman stealing one time out of economic desperation ($40k) who has since rehabilitated herself with therapy, a new job and repaying $5k."

Blah, blah, blah. It's obvious you're too stupid to see the differences in the cases explained in the article. The racist is you, because you only see the races of the two women involved, not the facts surrounding the cases.

Like I said, the author of the article you posted knew her target audience: Dumbasses like you who have no critical thinking skills.

reply

"The article I posted doesn't mention the races of the two women."

Of course it does, Sherlock! You're too dumb for words. I suggest you return to the article and use your own "critical thinking skills" to see the very obvious.

reply

I see you didn't say where it mentioned their race.

Because it isn't there.

Liar.

Show the exact quote.

reply

"The article I posted doesn't mention the races of the two women."

ROTFLMAO! The article clearly and obviously mentions the race of both women.

If you had proper "critical thinking skills" you would see the obvious.

I'm feeling charitable, so I just gave you a hint. Do you need another?

reply

No, it doesn't, liar.

Show the exact quote.

reply

"The article I posted doesn't mention the races of the two women."

My poor intellectually-challenged friend is confused by my hint which was "SEE THE OBVIOUS". I'll give another.

The race of each women is easy to find even for an illiterate like yourself. The hint is that reading is practically unnecessary, therefore a quote isn't what you need to find.

If you're still too stupid to find the obvious, I'll tell you.

But you must admit you have no critical thinking skills and that I'm smarter than you. Of course, if you still cant find it, then your lack of thinking skills and stupidity are obvious.

You just painted yourself into a corner!!!!

reply

It's obvious where you're going with this. They showed a picture of Hopkins, who is black.

But they didn't show a photo of Bosworth.

So if they never showed the black/white comparison, then how do you arrive at this?:

"your own link is criticizing the racism, too!"

Yes, you're a brain-dead moron.

reply

"But they didn't show a photo of Bosworth."

Yes, they did! But your critical-thinking skills are lacking. Once again, I'm going to help you to develop them. You're welcome.

The author is stating the same thing that my article did, but in a more subtle way. (Maybe her boss is a racist POS who would be upset about her article. Who knows?) She doesn't write that Hopkins is black. Instead, she shows you in a photo.

The next step is to find the rest of the story since she clearly wants the reader to know that there is racism involved in the sentencing of these two women. If that wasn't her main goal, then she wouldn't have done an article about both women. Her article is about comparing the sentences of a black woman and a white woman who committed a worst crime.

Now, you need to find her reference to Bosworth being white. If you need a hint, it's in your article. It clearly stands out.

reply

"Yes, they did!"

No, they didn't. Fucking liar.

"Her article is about comparing the sentences of a black woman and a white woman who committed a worst crime."

Do you actually think the writer chose that photograph to go with the story? Are you that stupid?

"Her article is about comparing the sentences of a black woman and a white woman who committed a worst crime."

Fucking delusional. If the author - which is the person who wrote the text - wanted to highlight the races, they would've put that in the text.

But an racist idiot like you sees race even when it's not there.

"Now, you need to find her reference to Bosworth being white. If you need a hint, it's in your article. It clearly stands out."

If it was there, you would have pointed it out in your first response. But you're lying, so you have to dance around it.

Dishonest piece of shit.

reply

You sound frustrated!

You give up much too easily!

Need more hints, my triggered grasshopper? The path to Debbie Bosworth's photo is obviously highlighted, underscored, emphasized, accentuated, etc. in that article. Seek the obvious, and it will be found.

There are about seven hints.

Seriously, it took me less than half a minute to find what is taking you days. Don't continue to disappoint me!

reply

Calling you a liar isn't frustrating.

But I'm sure walking around as stupid as you is frustrating.

STILL waiting...

reply

You're admitting your stupidity if you need me to tell you how to find Bosworth's photo.

I'll give you another day to find the obvious photo. After that time, you officially become the stupidest person on MC.

reply

STILL waiting, moron.

reply

"I'll give you another day to find the obvious photo. After that time, you officially become the stupidest person on MC."

reply

STILL waiting, idiot.

By the way, I know what you’re going to say. Just waiting for you to prove how completely retarded you are.

reply

Tick tock, my triggered grasshopper.

Time's a-wastin'.

reply

STILL waiting.

And waiting…

And waiting…

Zzzzz….

reply

Congratulations, Kinklink! You are now officially MC's dumbest poster!

The irony is that you couldn't find two photos in YOUR OWN link and one was at the beginning of the article in plain sight!!

To find Debbie Bosworth's photo all you have to do is click on the Debbie Bosworth link in the middle of the article. The one that's underlined and in blue staring you in the face! Duh!!!!

You're a dum dum!

reply

Yeah, I thought so. What a fucking moron.

"To find Debbie Bosworth's photo all you have to do is click on the Debbie Bosworth link in the middle of the article. "

No, it wasn't in the 'middle of the article'. It was at the bottom of the page, one of the advertisement links to other pages.

"The article clearly and obviously mentions the race of both women."

By that logic, other things the article 'clearly and obviously mentions':

New Shaftless Stair Lifts takes Only Hours to Install- See How Much They Cost
Fashion Historian Fact Checks The Marvelous Mrs. Maisel's Wardrobe
If You Need to Kill Time on Your Computer, this Fantasy Game is a Must-Have. No Install.
How to Declutter Your Home - 55 Things You Can Get Rid of Without Missing
14 US Maps That Sum Up The USA
See Why More Americans are Installing Stair Lift Elevators (See the Prices in 2021)
Portman delivers Infrastructure Deal: Darcy cartoon
This Star From 'Gilligan's Island' Is 101 Now & Lives A Humble Life
Former NASA Astronaut Explains Jeff Bezos's Space Flight
Colorado: Get Paid To Install Solar + Tesla Battery For No Cost At Install
Judge sends ex-St. Edward wrestling coach, Cleveland firefighter who sexually abused students to prison
Jim Jordan says he spoke to ex-President Trump on Jan. 6, the day of the Capitol riot
This Game Can Train Your Brain To Think Strategically
Inside A $23 Million Mega-Mansion Surrounded By A Lake
The Best Face Mask for Air Travel in 2021.
Parma man accused of beating his 5-year-old son to death indicted on charges that carry death penalty
Former nonprofit director says he retained Cleveland Councilman Kenneth Johnson’s relatives as financial problems mounted
The Most Famous Movie Filmed In Every U.S. State
Former FBI Agent Explains How to Negotiate
Resist Doing This With Retirement Funds At All Costs
Strongsville priest pleads guilty to federal charges of exploiting children
Inside Taylor Hill’s Rustic Nashville Retreat
If You Need to Kill Time on Your Computer, this City-Building Game is a Must-Have. No Install.
Woman sentenced 10 to 12 years in prison for killing construction worker on I-71 in Brook Park
Ohio high school football star accused of raping sleeping girl
56 Gloriously Awkward Photos Of Celebrities At Prom
Simone Biles Debunks Every Gymnastics Myth
No Annual Fees, Lots Of Perks. Compare Great Credit Cards
Mother of man shot by off-duty Cleveland police officer at grocery store says son never pointed gun at officer
Three teens with guns arrested in stolen car while leaving mall: Beachwood Police Blotter
30 Actors Who Were Also Incredible Athletes
Hugh Grant Breaks Down a Scene from 'The Undoing' with Director Susanne Bier
Celebrities Who Started as Beauty Queens
Property owner says former renter stole $6,800 worth of items: University Heights Police Blotter
Ohio Supreme Court vacates conviction, death sentence for man who pleaded guilty to

Yes, you are a complete idiot, claiming that advertisements are 'part of the article.' It's obvious now why you were reluctant to state where you found this 'evidence.'

Don't you ever get tired of being stupid?

reply

Kinkyink, the official stupidest poster on Moviechat, once again proves that stupid can't be fixed!

Your link to an article with photos of both women only reiterated my original post instead of refuting it, dum dum.

'Nuff said!

reply

Sorry Komrade Keelai. You got owned once again. Give it up, racist.

reply

You are an idiot who thinks advertisements are part of the article.

Literally brain-dead.

reply

Oh, oh! Kinky attempted critical-thinking and hasn't returned yet.

His brain imploded!

reply

Where'd you go?

I thought you were going to show me where this article mentions the race of both women, and 'criticized the racism'.?

I'm waiting.

reply

Here, I'll make it easy on you. The complete text of the article:

Former Maple Heights High School secretary sentenced to prison for stealing $40K from school

Former Maple Heights High School secretary Karla Hopkins is handcuffed after Cuyahoga County Common Pleas Court Judge Rick Bell sentenced her to 18 months in prison for stealing more than $40,000 from school funds in 2017 and 2018.

Updated Aug 04, 2021; Posted Aug 03, 2021

By Cory Shaffer, cleveland.com
CLEVELAND, Ohio -- A judge sentenced a former secretary at Maple Heights High Schools to spend 18 months in prison for stealing more than $40,000 from school money meant for the Class of 2018.

Cuyahoga County Common Pleas Court Judge Rick Bell told 51-year-old Karla Hopkins that she compounded her theft by liquidating her public employee pension shortly after the district discovered the theft. The move prevented the state from seizing the money to pay back the district.

Hopkins pleaded guilty in June to one count of theft in office, a third-degree felony. She faced anywhere from probation to three years in prison.

Hopkins stole the money between July 2017 and June 2018 from programs including the class of 2018′s dues and yearbook fees, auto tech, student council, flag-drill teams and book and ID badge fines, according to prosecutors.

Assistant Cuyahoga County Prosecutor James Gutierrez asked Bell to impose a 9 and 12 months prison sentence.

“She stole from kids, your honor,” Gutierrez said. “I have no idea why she did that.”

Defense attorney Bret Jordan told Bell that Hopkins, who has no prior criminal history, had been losing a struggle with mental health issues and a gambling addiction when she began stealing money. She completed an eight-week inpatient treatment program after her arrest and enrolled in a job development program that lined her up with a new job that she was supposed to begin on Tuesday. She also gave Jordan $5,000 to begin repaying the money that she stole, the attorney said.

Jordan said that if Bell sentenced Hopkins to prison, it would be harder for her to pay the district back because she would lose her job and have a more challenging time finding work after her release from prison. Jordan said she could fall into “a tailspin” if she did not continue receiving mental health and spiritual counseling that helped put her life back on track.

The Rev. Cynthia Rogers from Open Door Missionary Baptist Church told Bell that Hopkins had repeatedly expressed her remorse and desire to change during spiritual counseling sessions.

Hopkins repeatedly apologized in court on Tuesday.

“I want to pay the Maple Heights city students back,” she said. “I’m so sorry to Maple Heights City Schools for not living up to the trust that they entrusted in me. I had a lot of friends there. I’m so sorry to them all.”

Bell quickly quizzed Hopkins about her pension and how much money she took out after her arrest. She eventually said she took all of it out.

Ohio law requires any money left in the public pension account of someone convicted of theft in office to go toward restitution. Hopkins told Bell that she did not know about the law and that she took the money out to pay her bills because she lost her job.

“You knew that you had stolen money,” Bell said. “You didn’t use that money to pay restitution that you knew you owed.”

Bell told Hopkins that she compounded her situation by taking money out of her account.

“I understand and am grateful you’re going on a journey to better yourself,” the judge said. “But I think even your pastor would agree there has to be some consequence for your actions.”

Hopkins’ sentencing comes one day after another public employee who stole nearly $250,000 over 20 years from the village of Chagrin Falls received probation.

Debbie Bosworth, a clerk in the village’s utilities and building departments, pleaded no contest to 22 counts, including third-degree felony theft in office charges. She admitted to stealing more than $20,000 a year as residents paid their water bills in cash. Bosworth resigned from the village shortly after village officials caught her in 2019 and began paying back the stolen money before she was charged. She also kept her pension intact and allowed prosecutors to seize more than $200,000.

Common Pleas Court Judge Hollie Gallagher sentenced Bosworth to two years of probation.

reply

I'll edit:

Black women gets harsher sentence than white woman who committed worst crime. Typical example of systemic and institutional racism.

reply

Huh? Where are you imagining that to be?

Fucking liar.

reply

There is no such thing as racism.

People judge others on their looks and behavior.

And when you have a group that has acted like animals for so long they will be treated accordingly.

Anyone who burns down a police department will never get respect.
You can cry racism all.you want.

Anyone who uses ebonics will never get respect.

People will multiple baby mamas will never get respect

People on gov assistance for generations will never get respect.

And we are talking maybe 20% of.the population. Kinda hard not to notice such a small percentage of the country acting like this.



reply

You're describing prejudice and stereotypes.

Racism is different and exists as my article proves.

reply

Jeez! You're pathetic.

reply

Systemic racism. Something must be done.

reply

not surprising. the judge who sentenced that rich kid Ethan couch to probation for ten years after sgetting drunk, stealing his dads vehicle, driving drunk, crippling someone in the crash and killed 4 people.

sentenced a black teen to 20 years imprisonment for drunk driving that killed one person. the difference? (besides couch killing and injuring far more) couch stole his dads truck while the black teen stole someone else's so it was a felony.

if people dont think there is racism in the USA I cant convince them

reply

I was wondering if Bosworth might get parole now that this story has become national. Both she and the black teen should appeal their sentences.

A part of racism is to deny its existence. Similar to the way anti-Semites deny the Holocaust.

reply

they cant seem to think there is racism unless its someone in a hood yelling they are doing something because "I hate minorities". to them it has to be this blatant and no other forms of racism exist

reply

Exactly!

reply

Says the anti-Semite.

reply

500 people killed in Chicago, black mayor. Racism?

reply

Yes, there is systemic racism throughout the U.S.. Chicago is in the U.S..
Giving stiffer sentences to black people than whites who commit worse crimes = racism.

reply

But the Mayor is black and wants to defund the police.

reply

Stay on topic which is institutional racism in sentences as demonstrated by these two women.

Take your deflection attempt elsewhere.

reply

Deflection is your middle name.

reply

Embarrassing, pedophilic, senile old man shuffling around White House while real leader sits in his home in Florida.

This is called massive shameless election fraud

reply