MovieChat Forums > Politics > Trans people shouldn't be able to legall...

Trans people shouldn't be able to legally change their gender


If a man identifies as a woman, even if he has undergone surgery and hormone treatment, his DNA is still male.

Perhaps they should allow them to change their legal gender to 'trans - female identity', but to allow them to change their passport, their drivers licence, EVEN THEIR BIRTH CERTIFICATE to female, is nonsense.

That's a lie.

It's a flat out lie to say that a biological man is a woman. And legally so.

reply

Trans people should be able to legally change their gender

If a man identifies as a woman, even if he hasn't undergone surgery and hormone treatment, his gender is still female.

Perhaps they should allow them to change their passport, their drivers licence, EVEN THEIR BIRTH CERTIFICATE to female, to change their legal gender to 'trans - female identity' is nonsense.

That's a lie.

It's a flat out lie to say that a legal woman is a man. And legally so.



See how easy it is to nullify your views?

reply

A good solution would be to have two boxes, one for biological sex and another one for gender.

So a male that changes his gender could have 'male' in biological sex and 'female' in gender. That way, you don't miss information and both the biological sex and the identified gender are covered.

reply

I completely and very strongly disagree. Trans people should absolutely be able to legally change their gender, rather you like it or not. Sadly, there will always be bigots in society and people who think less of those who are different.

reply

Agreed.

reply

I can't think of a critical situation where it would make a difference.

πŸ€”


reply

So your saying you're against LGBT folks?? Shame on you!!!!

reply

IM ALL FOR ...PEOPLE...OF ALL KINDS...AND DONT HAVE A PROBLEM WITH TRANS PEOPLE CHANGING THEIR GENDER ON ANYTHING,EXCEPT...THE BIRTH CERTIFICATE...THATS REWRITING HISTORY...THEY WERE BORN WHAT THEY WERE BORN...IF THEY HAVE CHANGED,GREAT BUT THAT DOESNT RETROACTIVELY CHANGE THE PAST.πŸ™‚

reply

Just because your sex is male, it does not mean your gender is man. Man/woman/boy/girl are genders. Male and female are sexes.

Once you learn the difference, the conversation becomes simpler.

By the way, you'd have to have a serious brain injury to think this genetic female with XX chromosomes must absolutely identify as a woman.

https://point5cc.com/wp-content/uploads/2016/05/Point5cc-Blog-TransFitness2.jpg

I really have to wonder, where does your madness end?

reply

Birth certificates show sex, not "gender" as you define it. They shouldn't be able to change these documents.

reply

I don't care if a person's birth certificate keeps their sex. You said legal gender. There's no such thing as legal gender on a birth certificate. You are confusing gender with sex. Just like you did when you said "female identity." Male and female are not identities.

Gender is what you identify as. Sex is biological.

reply