MovieChat Forums > Harry Potter > I have read spoilers for Cursed Child Pa...

I have read spoilers for Cursed Child Parts 1 & 2 online...


Basically spoilers coming from the Part 1 preview. And it sounds like really bad fanfiction. It sounds quite horrifyingly bad if its true.

Edit: I have now read the spoilers from part 2 and if this is all true, it sounds like Rowling lost her mind by approving this. Apparently, Bellatrix and Voldemort had a child that was born before DH which makes no sense canonically and it just absolutely horrifying storytelling.

reply

Umm where did you find said spoilers? I have only found some and they are minor plot details.

edit just found them, I think someone is trolling hard. the things I have read from people who have seen it,do not make any implications of that at all. I think some details are accurate, but I don't know about the whole time travel thing. It does not make sense, so I really do hope its a troll, because if not what the *beep*.

<3MICHELLE<3

reply

It was directly copy-pasted from Snitchseeker who have taken it down now after JKR called out people for posting spoilers, so it's true.

reply

Yeah, it sounds like really lazy fanfiction.

reply

It really is. It's not even good fanfiction. A bunch of it makes no sense within the context of what we know about the characters. It's ridiculous.

reply

Jo directly called out Hypable for posting two spoilers, which I think are true. I think the other stuff is bull crap because like it is stated below it goes against everything about the characters and her original canonical work.

<3MICHELLE<3

reply

I would like to believe that. But it seems to be coming from multiple sources, including those who have seen it. Hopefully it is just a elaborate hoax because it goes against prior characterization and concepts as introduced in the books.

reply

you do realize that the plot is YEARS after everything happened when Harry killed Voldemort.

a lot of it makes sense.

and the people who watched the play say it's amazing.it's getting rave reviews.

just wait for the script and then judge.

reply

I am sorry but years later is no excuse for butchered characterization and time concepts. I mean Harry and Albus sound awful. And the whole time travel stuff makes zero sense when compared to the concept when it was introduced in POA. As for the rave reviews, that's how it is for previews for anything. Even bad movies get get great initial reactions before the official release. The story, if accurate, sounds awful. I'm sure the production and the acting is wonderful but for those of us who won't be able to see the play and will only read the script book, it sounds dreadful.

reply