MovieChat Forums > Harry Potter > Something I noted about the Potterverse

Something I noted about the Potterverse


There is a strong element of bigotry existing in the magical community in the Potterverse; because of the way the wizards carried/wielded power it made them feel superior and they decide to use it for their own purposes. And beyond bigotry, there is a sense of inflexibility and intolerance; these are people with strong traditions that do not enjoy conventions being bent or broken, partly out of necessary secrecy and partly because of


The following examples are below (feel free to correct me if I am wrong):
- Gellert Grindelwald believed in the superiority of wizards and sought to make a takeover of the world.


- Salazar Slytherin believed in pure-blood and created the Chamber of Secrets at Hogwarts for his heirs to use to strike at Muggle-born children. This passed on to his heirs...

- Marvolo Gaunt, who believed in the purity of his bloodline and disowned his daughter Merope when she eloped with a handsome Muggle

- Tom Riddle, Merope’s son, believed at a young age that he was superior to others. He went on to become the dreaded Lord Voldemort and launched a takeover of the magical community where he instilled an atmosphere of fear and oppression over everyone, his followers included.


Thanks to Lord Voldemort, many wizards’ lives were ruined, but society made them pretty much a mess and without any option, and it was just a matter of getting a flame going.
- Barty Crouch and his son Jr were torn apart because Crouch never had time for his son and so drove him to become a fanatical supporter of Lord Voldemort. Crouch Jr killed his own father, and got his soul torn out of his body as a result.

- Dolores Umbridge was a pretty unpleasant character to all whether they were pure-blood or not, but putting her in power was the worst thing that could have happened because she made everyone’s lives a nightmare.

- Severus Snape led a tragic life: having lost the love of his life to his rival (admittedly his own fault, but he was provoked), he had nothing left but to join the Death Eaters. But when Voldemort killed them both, he repented and joined Dumbledore to stop him.


Even the fairly heroic characters displayed darkness in their pasts thanks to the magical culture:
- Albus Dumbledore joined Grendelwald and believed in his crusade of putting wizards in power, but it wasn’t until he got his own sister killed that he realized this was wrong.

- Minister Cornelius Fudge actually didn’t care about blood, but he was too frightened to imagine that Lord Voldemort was in power and launched a campaign, headed by Umbridge, to discredit Dumbledore. By the time he saw the error of his ways it was too late, he lost his job.

- Rufus Scrimgeour, Fudge’s replacement as Minister, went the opposite direction from Fudge: he arrested everyone who had a slight connection to the Death Eaters and tried to force Harry to be a Minister puppet to present a positive pro-active image.

- James Potter and Lily Evans, parents of the heroes, were seen as Hogwarts’ top students. But even they had dark pasts, with James being a bully to Severus and Lily breaking off relations with him (I would call this the most forgivable though, they were young and maybe reconciliation may have been possible if not for Voldemort)

- Kreacher and Dobby spent their whole lives in servitude to wizards, not knowing this was wrong. And only Hermione cared for elves enough to strive to give them a better life; before her no one else had really tried to do so.

- The Ravenclaw house is notable for only accepting exceptionally smarter students, and in this case founder Rowena Ravenclaw incurred the envy of her daughter. (Although I think this housing concept could have worked out better, maybe Hermione should have been in Ravenclaw and be a friend of the Gryffindors Harry and Ron or something)


Things only really changed after Harry Potter defeated Voldemort for the final time. The epilogue mentioned that the Sorting Hat now took mention of where the student wanted to be, rather than sorting him/her into a house based on their qualifications. This element of choice meant that they could go where they liked, and that they could be accepted for it. The element of tolerance was increased and things were less strict and easier now.


07/08/06... 786... the sentinel of Allah has arrived.

reply

Haha well I wouldn't have brought it up but if we're talking about the theme of prejudice in Harry Potter (which is a fairly grown-up theme even if the books are aimed at children) then it's worth considering that this prejudice could be so integral to the wizarding world that it is lying unconscious in even the good characters. It's even something of a running joke in the series about how clueless the Weasleys are about muggles when they could actually learn these things if they were really interested in them (seriously, all those Latin spells Ron has to learn and he can't grasp the word "telephone"?!) as opposed to just thinking of muggle life as a quaint amusement. But no, I don't think Arthur is evil, just unknowingly patronising.

reply