MovieChat Forums > Indian Cinema > OT: Some noirs I saw recently

OT: Some noirs I saw recently


Nightmare Alley (1947) - A psychological drama with decent performances, especially by Helen Walker who plays a psychiatrist. The climax could've been done better but the setup is solid.

Mystery Street (1950) - A cut and dried police procedural with a tight script. More of these please!

Act of Violence (1949) - A brilliant film, with a wonderful screenplay. You think the movie is going somewhere, but then it stops at a totally unexpected point, before actually ending up where you thought it was going, and it could never have gone anywhere else. Robert Ryan is great as the wounded man, and Phyllis Thaxter makes an impression in a very short role and Janet Leigh plays a wholesome middle-class wife with gusto, even though she appears to be very young for that role.

Criss Cross (1949) - Sadly, didn't hold my attention much, even though there's nothing wrong with this film. The beginning of the heist scene was brilliantly shot. Some of the screenplays for these noirs are truly memorable.

reply

Nightmare Alley (1947) - A psychological drama with decent performances, especially by Helen Walker who plays a psychiatrist. The climax could've been done better but the setup is solid.

this was strongly recommended to me by someone who posts here occasionally. i might watch it soon.

Why hang on to antiquated notions like "the soil is like my mother?" - Man

reply

I got most of these from a list you posted here.

reply

I might have recommended that one but may be somebody else also did. I need to see Noir. it's been long. Robert Ryan's movie would do well. Any recommendations?

-

reply

Yeah man, I'd recommend Act of Violence. Have you seen Odd Man Out? I'd recommend that too. The climax is simply brilliant and so sad.

reply

It's amazing movie and I saw it in 2012-13 when I watches a lot of noirs. Mystery Street (1950) I have not seen from your list. How about that for a recommendation? Will try to find it.

-

reply

Mystery Street is a very straight police procedural. I like such films but I would hardly put this as the epitome of noir.

I recalled another Ryan movie, Clash by Night. Not really a full noir, but the cast is amazing, and it's directed by Fritz Lang.

reply

aj, strongly recommend THE SET UP. its only 70 minutes long.

ON DANGEROUS GROUND has a great score by herrmann. and its located in a really snowy place.

CROSSFIRE is pretty good too. it has a really nasty RYAN and a cool MITCHUM.

Why hang on to antiquated notions like "the soil is like my mother?" - Man

reply

The Set up seems to be highly praised. I have it and will probably watch now that you recommended.

have seen the other two and liked them very much, Pimpin.

-

reply