MovieChat Forums > Movie Awards > Which other actress can you imagine in A...

Which other actress can you imagine in Arrival


in the place of Amy Adams? I don't think her performance is the best of the year but her presence is what made the film great. Like Villeneuve said, she is the soul of the film.

I can't think of any contemporary actress who can evoke that much heart and poignancy.

Make a move, Reindeer Games..

reply

she was in The Day The Earth Stood Still (2008)

an alien is humanity's only hope for survival so it takes advice from Basil Fawlty

reply

I think Alicia Vikander could have down it. Potentially a bit young, and possibly a bit to extraordinarily beautiful, though.

And How about Olivia Colman? I'd have loved to have seen her encountering the aliens and she certainly possesses the soul for it.

reply

My old reply didn't get saved here so I'll say Natalie Portman and Jessica Chastain again.

reply

Jennifer Connelly is a great choice!!

Also Rachel Weisz, Tilda Swinton and a younger Liv Ullmann

reply

Jennifer or Rachel would have been great. After Constantine and Doctor Strange, im having trouble seeing Tilda in ordinary mortal roles.

reply

Rachel McAdams or Claire Danes.

reply

Given that Contact was a similar film in many ways, I'd have to say Jodie Foster....

reply