Tin Man or Iron Man?
Who's a greater character?
They both have heart problems. But while one stays by his friends with only his trusty axe (and the occasional giant wrench), the other FIGHTS with his friends, and apparently has to keep inventing gizmos that are frankly very showy.
I don't want to influence your vote, but as Bob Browning said, "less is more" - go for the man who was outstanding in his field for a full year!
"Professor Marvel never guesses - he knows!"