MovieChat Forums > Roseanne (1988) Discussion > Roseanne Conner advocating spanking make...

Roseanne Conner advocating spanking makes no sense


I know that there's a belief among many conservatives (who Roseanne's trying to portray and appeal to) that the reason "kids these days" are so out of control is because they weren't spanked as a kid, but hearing Roseanne Conner imply the same thing in tonight's episode made no sense, if we take the history of her character into account at all. They did a whole episode about it in the original series - the one where Roseanne lost control, spanked DJ for stealing the family car, felt horrible about it, faced her own trauma from when her and Jackie's father used to hit them and promised DJ she'd never hit him again, no matter what he did. So, now, we're supposed to believe that that same character would not only advocate spanking but also call her granddaughter a bitch and jerk her by the neck and shove her head in the sink? Come on. The whole thing just felt like Roseanne pandering to conservatives instead of protecting the consistency and legacy of the Roseanne Conner character.

Now, I'm not saying spanking is good or bad (or is a liberal vs conservative thing), I'm just saying that Roseanne Conner advocating it - whether she's supposed to be a conservative now or not - makes no sense.

reply

My parents didn’t spank me or my sister. My husband and I did spank. I was stunned one day when my mom admitted her and my dad should have been stricter and spanked. So maybe Roseanne saw she made a mistake not doing it.

reply

See, that would actually make sense, but without a one-off line about how maybe she wasn't strict enough with them because she was afraid she'd turn into her abusive father or something like that, it ruins Roseanne's character a little (or at least isn't consistent). I still think it was just thrown in to pander to conservatives. I mean, the conservative media and commenters are already praising it: "'Roseanne' tackles PC parenting in second episode of revival" http://www.foxnews.com/entertainment/2018/04/03/roseanne-tackles-pc-parenting-in-second-episode-revival.html

reply