All is Lost is way better
IMO
sharebut is it better than Perfect Storm?
shareAgree about All is Lost. This one even borrows a sequence from Redford's when she patches the side of the boat as he did, except that she used Duck Tape rather than a fiberglass patch. I know Duck Tape is great stuff, good for lots of temporary repairs, but I doubt it could stand the rigors of salt water pounding against it.
Still, this wasn't a bad movie. Just not great.
I thought both were pretty damn good, but if you twist my arm I'll say that All Is Lost was a little bit better.
share