A puff piece...


Saw on Netflix last night. A few chuckles here and there, but this is never gonna be a Christmas classic.

Like many comedies these days, a lot of the story and dialogue seems improv'd. For example, what was the bit with the dress up Nativity scene? I've never heard of that as something that families do. The bit with the little girl sexing herself up by baring her navel was a bit squirmy. The in-movie improv scene was awkward to sit through... not Lithgow, but Farrell's clueless laughing.

There's a certain 'randomness' to the story and it seems to wobble a bit trying to find a central message.

reply

Not sure how many families specifically have participated in live nativity scenes, but they are a real thing. It's not something made up for the movie.

reply

Yes, in my city there is a very popular Nativity play put on for the public every year. It's a church organized event and it tells the story of the birth of JC. I've never heard it being done by a family as some sort of living tableau... that struck me as weird.

Other things:

i. Mel Gibson's character is supposed to be an ex-astronaut, yet he's described as a long-time horn dog by his son. Astronauts are way too busy and buttoned down to be caught up in this sort of stuff. (Coincidentally an ex-school mate of mine - Chris Hadfield - became an astronaut. I've followed his career over the decades... those guys have ZERO downtime.)

ii. The whole 'Do They Know It's Christmas' sing along... there's something wrong about trying to wring warm feelings from a song that's about mass starvation in Africa. Particularly, since it is still ongoing... now perhaps worse than when the song first came out.

iii. The thermostat scene... not even mildly funny, but, man, the actors kept plugging away at it, trying to make it a 'thing'.

reply

"Like many comedies these days, a lot of the story and dialogue seems improv'd"

...a big problem I have with a lot of recent comedies. Just write a funny script, don't think of the joke on the spot.

reply