Some things misfired (spoilers)
I generally liked it. I loved seeing the characters and that world recreated again.
But why does the 32-year old Rory still make such bad choices? Friends with Benefits? One night stands with strangers? It cheapens or nullifies everything she learned over the seven seasons.
In Fall, the 48-year old Lorelai is still capable of flip outs at that level? Has she learned nothing? That whole phone call to her mother was not predicated on anything and just a mawkish failure. I just turned it off at that point.
The Luke and Lorelai characters have zero chemistry with one another anymore, which really casts a weird pall over the ending.
Winter and Spring were the best episodes. The ending of Fall just left me with emptiness.