MovieChat Forums > One Day at a Time (2017) Discussion > Doesn't Hold a Candle to the Original

Doesn't Hold a Candle to the Original


It seems like a show where the producers didn't think they needed any writers because it would write itself. When that happens, you end up with not so much a storyline and dialogue but rehashes of stereotypes for forced laughs. You have the strong Latina woman, the feminist teenaged Latina, the crazy Latina grandma, the insensitive Anglo/Jewish boss and insensitive anglo/Jewish landlord who the strong Latina women try in vain to change.

On the original, you had the best MILF of the seventies in the often braless Bonnie Franklyn, a cute teenager (I was twelve when the show came out) and her brassy but confused sister. For comic relief, you had the working class superintendent who vastly over-estimates his charm. Yes, those were stereotypes also, but after the first show played out all the laughs to be mined for stereotypes, the real writing and acting talent showed.

Based on the first three episodes, this show intends thinks it's "green" to recycle characters and plotlines.





When the debate is lost, slander becomes the tool of the loser. - Socrates



reply

Have you actually watched? The boss/doctor is a very sweet man. And Schneider is a much more layered character than in the original.

reply

This is my second post here and the second time I've gotten a condescending suggestion that I haven't watched the show. Do you ODAAT fans always assume anyone who disagrees with you must be doing so out of ignorance?




When the debate is lost, slander becomes the tool of the loser. - Socrates



reply

The conclusions you have reached are so far off, I had to assume you either didn't watch, or watched only the pilot.

reply

I don't know. I don't think the original series has much relevance now. It's not a classic people are constantly watching in syndication. I like the subjects that have been discussed. I appreciate the modern outlook. And I'm a fan of Justina Machado. Also, it may be shallow, but when it comes to an extraneous character like Schneider I'd prefer eye candy over silly shenanigans.

reply

I agree. I don't think the younger generation even cares about the original. Maybe not even heard of it. It doesn't live in syndication like many other shows of that era. I wouldn't say it was a "classic" show.

reply